docs: record R4 design review failures

2026-08-11 11:17:59 +08:00
parent 0a340457e7
commit 062770666e
18 changed files with 72 additions and 26 deletions
@@ -0,0 +1,24 @@
+# Context Manifest: ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4
+
+> Task ID: `ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4`
+> Revision: `1`
+> Mode: `deep`
+> Budget exception: `none`
+
+## 必须读取（默认不超过 8 项）
+
+| 路径或稳定引用 | Revision / 范围 | 为什么本 Goal 必须读 |
+|---|---|---|
+| `AGENTS.md` | fixed source | repository and design-stage boundary |
+| `.agent-taskgraph/PROJECT.md` | rev-6 | runtime, originality and Frozen rules |
+| `.agent-taskgraph/roles/experience-production-reviewer-r4/ROLE.md` | rev-6 | independent role boundary |
+| current `dispatch.md` and `goal.md` | context-1 | identity, fixed source and gates |
+| `.agent-taskgraph/spec.md` | design-spec-r3 | frozen product contract |
+| `.agent-taskgraph/graph.yaml#v2_experience_review_r4` | graph-r9 | dependency and route |
+| `docs/reviews/PRE_DEVELOPMENT_READINESS_AUDIT.md` | fixed db932cf | current evidence and exclusions |
+| `.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R3/report.md` | R3-FAIL | failure history only |
+
+## 按需检索（先搜索，再局部读取）
+
+- `docs/presentation/`, `docs/content/`, `docs/product/` and the two exact reference authorities named by the Goal.
+- Never read later product changes, worker chats, other games, commercial payloads, superseded HTML/media or release material into judgment.
@@ -0,0 +1,21 @@
+# Dispatch Bootstrap: ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4
+
+| Field | Value |
+|---|---|
+| Task ID | ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4 |
+| Dispatch ID | dispatch:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4:attempt-1 |
+| Role ref | role:experience-production-reviewer-r4 |
+| Role profile | roles/experience-production-reviewer-r4/ROLE.md |
+| Role lifecycle | task-scoped |
+| Team revision | rev-6 |
+| Goal ref | task:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4 |
+| Context manifest | context.md |
+| Context revision | 1 |
+| Continuity | fresh R4 role and fresh HAPI session; R1-R3 are history only |
+| Session ID | 0e8eec99-d95f-4b98-a9bf-cb5ac46433e1 |
+| Expected identity ACK | IDENTITY_READY dispatch_id=dispatch:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4:attempt-1 role=role:experience-production-reviewer-r4 team_revision=rev-6 goal=task:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4 context_revision=1 |
+| Delivery | SENT: 2026-08-11T10:56:00+08:00 via HAPI peer; dispatch:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4:attempt-1 |
+| Identity ACK | VERIFIED: IDENTITY_READY dispatch_id=dispatch:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4:attempt-1 role=role:experience-production-reviewer-r4 team_revision=rev-6 goal=task:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4 context_revision=1 |
+| ACK evidence | HAPI 0e8eec99-d95f-4b98-a9bf-cb5ac46433e1 exact standalone ACK observed before review commands at 2026-08-11T11:00:42+08:00 |
+
+Read Role, PROJECT, context, Goal and direct evidence in that order. Return the exact identity ACK before reviewing.
@@ -0,0 +1,64 @@
+# Goal: ABG-V2 Experience And Production Review R4
+
+> Stage: fixed-revision pre-development independent review
+> Started: 2026-08-11T10:44:55+08:00
+> Task ID: `ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4`
+> Baseline: `9c7e86bffd0d61d184a60d42d95036c2cb17f9fe; branch=review/abg-v2-experience-r4; clean`
+> Accepted 上一阶段: `bcb2931356bb416f2bf617e3704d33bb8566e200`
+> Fixed product source: `db932cfc00af4e359babf8a81447b0affd0184fa`
+> Frozen spec: `.agent-taskgraph/spec.md` revision `design-spec-r3`
+> Graph node: `.agent-taskgraph/graph.yaml#v2_experience_review_r4` revision `graph-r9`
+> Independent contract: `docs/reviews/PRE_DEVELOPMENT_READINESS_AUDIT.md` at the fixed source
+> Context manifest: `context.md`
+> Context revision: `1`
+> Legal terminal: **ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4 PASS** or **ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4 FAIL: <earliest failed product boundary>** or **ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4 INVALID: <review environment boundary>**
+
+## Objective
+
+Independently audit immutable revision `db932cfc00af4e359babf8a81447b0affd0184fa`
+from zero for an understandable landscape player experience and a feasible,
+original 2D Japanese hand-drawn art, animation, VFX and audio production plan.
+This is a design-authority review, not runtime, screenshot or human acceptance.
+
+## 图输入、输出与写入范围
+
+- 直接依赖（needs）：`v2_experience_reintegration`
+- 必须读取（consumes）：fixed source, design-spec-r3, presentation/content authorities and current reference documents
+- 必须产出（produces）：one read-only PASS/FAIL/INVALID terminal with exact evidence
+- 唯一写入范围（writes）：none in the repository; reviewer-owned temporary evidence only
+- 路由：PASS -> `v2_review_synthesis`; FAIL/INVALID -> `failed`; 最大尝试 1
+
+## 分配记录
+
+- Role ref：`role:experience-production-reviewer-r4`
+- 角色职责：Independently verify fixed-revision comprehension, page coverage, visual/audio production feasibility, accessibility and originality
+- 角色生命周期：task-scoped
+- 派给：experience-production-reviewer-r4
+- 分配理由：职责匹配
+- 连续性：fresh R4 role and fresh HAPI session; R1-R3 are history only
+- 工作区：`/Users/wusumac/Documents/game/tmp/aetherbound-guild-worktrees/review-experience-r4`（分支：`review/abg-v2-experience-r4`）
+- Runtime requested：`runtime=hapi; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=bypassPermissions; visibility=visible`
+- Runtime observed：`runtime=hapi; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=yolo; visibility=visible`
+- Runtime verification：`VERIFIED; pre-dispatch 2026-08-11T10:55:09+08:00`
+- Session evidence：`HAPI 0e8eec99-d95f-4b98-a9bf-cb5ac46433e1; PID 92955; verification a57ca97c-7c1c-4773-b614-778f3f3b8437; runtime-evidence.json; zero-message watermark`
+- Dispatch bootstrap：`dispatch.md`
+- Dispatch message：`SENT: 2026-08-11T10:56:00+08:00 via HAPI peer; dispatch:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4:attempt-1`
+- Identity ACK：`VERIFIED: IDENTITY_READY dispatch_id=dispatch:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4:attempt-1 role=role:experience-production-reviewer-r4 team_revision=rev-6 goal=task:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4 context_revision=1`
+- 完整启动方式：HAPI Hub helper spawn after fixed control worktree preflight
+
+## Required Gates
+
+1. Create a fresh archive of exactly `db932cf`, prove its commit ID/tree, and show canonical `main` still contains that revision with no product-authority diff after it.
+2. Run Python compile, validator self-test/full/JSON; require cases=20, errors=0, pages=50, audio-bound pages=50, bindings=34 and exact content/audio counts.
+3. Map the complete first-play chain: inspect four provisional offers, compare and choose two, revise before commit, create run, hire two more, equip, reorder, choose risk, observe battle, read casualty/reward and reach the next Market.
+4. Audit all 50 page/state definitions for landscape phone/tablet, safe areas, focus/controller/touch, empty/loading/error/locked/disabled/confirmation/interruption, EN/zh_CN and 130% text.
+5. Verify the ordered horizontal line and up to 10 deployed members remain readable for order, reach, movement, protection, health/status, deterministic outcomes, death, rewards, speed and inspect/pause without manual skill UI.
+6. Verify the UI and art use one exposed-front/protected-rear direction and all ten recruit-generation fields have deterministic content-to-art mappings with coherent counts.
+7. Audit 42 professions, 36 traits, 320 equipment, 60 artifacts, 8 regions, 100 ordinary/elite enemies and 16 bosses for countable production families, silhouette differentiation and page/state presentation.
+8. Audit 32 music, 76 ambience, 228 SFX and 32 voice intents, including `OUT-006`, all 50 screens, priority/ducking, lifecycle, mute, low-power, captions and generated-Recruit voice scope.
+9. Audit originality against only `REFERENCE_RUNTIME_CENSUS.md` and `TRANSFERABLE_STRUCTURE_LESSONS.md`; reject copied names, prose, formulas, layout expression, commercial media, code or assets, and reject retired fixed-cast/relationship scope.
+10. Stop at the earliest boundary. Product contradiction is FAIL; harness/import/command/evidence failure is INVALID. Do not repair or write the repository.
+
+## Frozen
+
+No repository writes, repair, commit, push, HTML, runtime, media, package or release actions. Human understanding/fun, visual/listening, device and release remain open after PASS.
@@ -0,0 +1,44 @@
+# Ledger: ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4
+
+| Field | Value |
+|---|---|
+| 任务 ID | ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4 |
+| Goal ref | task:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4 |
+| Goal current path | queue/failed/ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4/goal.md |
+| Context manifest | context.md |
+| Context revision | 1 |
+| Role ref | role:experience-production-reviewer-r4 |
+| Role lifecycle | task-scoped |
+| Role profile | roles/experience-production-reviewer-r4/ROLE.md |
+| Role continuity | fresh R4 role and fresh HAPI session; R1-R3 are history only |
+| Reviewer Role ref | PENDING |
+| Reviewer Role profile | PENDING |
+| Frozen spec | .agent-taskgraph/spec.md design-spec-r3 |
+| Graph node | .agent-taskgraph/graph.yaml#v2_experience_review_r4 |
+| 依赖/路由 | needs: v2_experience_reintegration; PASS -> v2_review_synthesis; FAIL/INVALID -> failed |
+| 状态 | failed |
+| 负责人 | experience-production-reviewer-r4 |
+| 分配理由 | 职责匹配 |
+| 轮次 | 第 1 次 |
+| 开始时间 | 2026-08-11T10:44:55+08:00 |
+| 最后更新 | 2026-08-11T11:14:28+08:00 |
+| 验收结果 | FAIL: Gate 7 hidden-hybrid profession content-to-art production binding |
+| 日志指针 | HAPI 0e8eec99; PID 92955; verification a57ca97c; runtime-evidence.json; `/tmp/abg-v2-experience-review-r4.4t4bzY/terminal.txt` SHA `a304e953...` |
+| Runtime requested | runtime=hapi; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=bypassPermissions; visibility=visible |
+| Runtime observed | runtime=hapi; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=yolo; visibility=visible |
+| Runtime verification | VERIFIED |
+| Session ID | 0e8eec99-d95f-4b98-a9bf-cb5ac46433e1 |
+| Runtime evidence | runtime-evidence.json |
+| Dispatch bootstrap | dispatch.md |
+| Dispatch message | SENT: 2026-08-11T10:56:00+08:00 via HAPI peer; dispatch:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4:attempt-1 |
+| Identity ACK | VERIFIED: IDENTITY_READY dispatch_id=dispatch:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4:attempt-1 role=role:experience-production-reviewer-r4 team_revision=rev-6 goal=task:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4 context_revision=1 |
+| 等待归属 | 在等谁：PMO；等什么：route bounded hidden-profession art binding repair |
+
+## State History
+
+| Time | From -> To | Operator | Evidence | Next |
+|---|---|---|---|---|
+| 2026-08-11T10:44:55+08:00 | created -> inbox | PMO | fixed source `db932cf`, graph-r9 and R4 dual-review authorization | create clean control worktree and verified HAPI session |
+| 2026-08-11T10:55:20+08:00 | inbox -> inbox | PMO | HAPI `0e8eec99` pre-dispatch VERIFIED with zero-message watermark | commit binding and send rendered bootstrap |
+| 2026-08-11T11:00:42+08:00 | inbox -> active | PMO | bootstrap delivered; exact standalone rev-6 IDENTITY_READY observed before review commands | monitor without interrupting |
+| 2026-08-11T11:14:28+08:00 | active -> failed | PMO | legal FAIL on immutable `db932cf`; tree `21b7c81`; terminal SHA `a304e953c8d6927a6d0a8273fc2a97c843174d5c1074a3bf3732457f1981ccb8` | repair only PF-H01..H06 art parent/silhouette/motion bindings |
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
+# ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4 Report
+
+Terminal: `ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4 FAIL: hidden-hybrid profession content-to-art production binding`
+
+- Fixed source: `db932cfc00af4e359babf8a81447b0affd0184fa`
+- Fixed tree: `21b7c81886c02cd07a632d71df62e25911aa416c`
+- Reviewer: HAPI `0e8eec99-d95f-4b98-a9bf-cb5ac46433e1`
+- Terminal evidence: `/tmp/abg-v2-experience-review-r4.4t4bzY/terminal.txt`; SHA-256 `a304e953c8d6927a6d0a8273fc2a97c843174d5c1074a3bf3732457f1981ccb8`
+
+Passed before failure: immutable-source verification, validator self/full/JSON, anti-dominance, first-play chain, 50-screen state coverage, horizontal-line readability and generated-Recruit crosswalk.
+
+At Gate 7, content resolves `PF-H01..H06` parent pairs, mechanics and production briefs, while art retains unresolved parent bindings and assigns incompatible silhouettes/motion codes. Examples include H02 bell-hilt/cadence versus bow/vial `RELEASE/DEPLOY`, H03 bow-spear versus lantern/hammer `HEAVY/PULSE`, and H04 backpack automaton versus cord/folio `SWEEP/CHANNEL`.
+
+No downstream audio/originality PASS was promoted. The reviewer made no repository write.
@@ -0,0 +1,39 @@
+{
+  "status": "VERIFIED",
+  "phase": "pre-dispatch",
+  "verification_id": "a57ca97c-7c1c-4773-b614-778f3f3b8437",
+  "goal_ref": "task:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4",
+  "session_id": "0e8eec99-d95f-4b98-a9bf-cb5ac46433e1",
+  "machine_id": "a15888ad-d405-4884-a407-c28ddd8b397c",
+  "machine_name": "小吴家",
+  "machine_host": "wusumacdeMac-mini.local",
+  "pid": "92955",
+  "flavor": "codex",
+  "cwd": "/Users/wusumac/Documents/game/tmp/aetherbound-guild-worktrees/review-experience-r4",
+  "model": "gpt-5.6-sol",
+  "effort": "xhigh",
+  "permission": "yolo",
+  "messages_received": 0,
+  "message_watermark": {
+    "latest_page_count": 0,
+    "latest_message_id": "",
+    "snapshot_head_seq": null,
+    "snapshot_head_at": null,
+    "epoch": 0,
+    "captured_at": "2026-08-11T02:55:09.363025+00:00"
+  },
+  "active": true,
+  "thinking": false,
+  "lifecycle": "running",
+  "catalog": {
+    "status": "VERIFIED",
+    "source": "/api/machines/:id/codex-models",
+    "checked_at": "2026-08-11T02:55:08.692014+00:00",
+    "model": "gpt-5.6-sol",
+    "effort": "xhigh",
+    "model_supported": true,
+    "effort_supported": true
+  },
+  "evidence": "HAPI Hub session metadata, model catalog, and message watermark",
+  "verified_at": "2026-08-11T02:55:09.363070+00:00"
+}
@@ -0,0 +1,24 @@
+# Context Manifest: ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4
+
+> Task ID: `ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4`
+> Revision: `1`
+> Mode: `deep`
+> Budget exception: `none`
+
+## 必须读取（默认不超过 8 项）
+
+| 路径或稳定引用 | Revision / 范围 | 为什么本 Goal 必须读 |
+|---|---|---|
+| `AGENTS.md` | fixed source | repository and design-stage boundary |
+| `.agent-taskgraph/PROJECT.md` | rev-6 | runtime, originality and Frozen rules |
+| `.agent-taskgraph/roles/systems-integrity-reviewer-r4/ROLE.md` | rev-6 | independent role boundary |
+| current `dispatch.md` and `goal.md` | context-1 | identity, fixed source and gates |
+| `.agent-taskgraph/spec.md` | design-spec-r3 | frozen product contract |
+| `.agent-taskgraph/graph.yaml#v2_systems_review_r4` | graph-r9 | dependency and route |
+| `docs/reviews/PRE_DEVELOPMENT_READINESS_AUDIT.md` | fixed db932cf | current evidence and exclusions |
+| `.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R3/report.md` | R3-FAIL | failure history only |
+
+## 按需检索（先搜索，再局部读取）
+
+- `docs/product/`, `docs/content/`, `docs/reviews/DESIGN_VALIDATION_CONTRACT.md`, `tools/validate_predevelopment_design.py`, `tools/simulate_anti_dominance.py` and the fixed fixture.
+- Never read later product changes, worker chats, other games, superseded HTML/media or release material into judgment.
@@ -0,0 +1,21 @@
+# Dispatch Bootstrap: ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4
+
+| Field | Value |
+|---|---|
+| Task ID | ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 |
+| Dispatch ID | dispatch:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4:attempt-1 |
+| Role ref | role:systems-integrity-reviewer-r4 |
+| Role profile | roles/systems-integrity-reviewer-r4/ROLE.md |
+| Role lifecycle | task-scoped |
+| Team revision | rev-6 |
+| Goal ref | task:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 |
+| Context manifest | context.md |
+| Context revision | 1 |
+| Continuity | fresh R4 role and fresh HAPI session; R1-R3 are history only |
+| Session ID | ba21ab5a-b78f-4c30-ad12-94b457dcec71 |
+| Expected identity ACK | IDENTITY_READY dispatch_id=dispatch:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4:attempt-1 role=role:systems-integrity-reviewer-r4 team_revision=rev-6 goal=task:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 context_revision=1 |
+| Delivery | SENT: 2026-08-11T10:56:00+08:00 via HAPI peer; dispatch:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4:attempt-1 |
+| Identity ACK | VERIFIED: IDENTITY_READY dispatch_id=dispatch:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4:attempt-1 role=role:systems-integrity-reviewer-r4 team_revision=rev-6 goal=task:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 context_revision=1 |
+| ACK evidence | HAPI ba21ab5a-b78f-4c30-ad12-94b457dcec71 exact standalone ACK observed before review commands at 2026-08-11T11:00:42+08:00 |
+
+Read Role, PROJECT, context, Goal and direct evidence in that order. Return the exact identity ACK before reviewing.
@@ -0,0 +1,64 @@
+# Goal: ABG-V2 Systems Integrity Review R4
+
+> Stage: fixed-revision pre-development independent review
+> Started: 2026-08-11T10:44:55+08:00
+> Task ID: `ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4`
+> Baseline: `9c7e86bffd0d61d184a60d42d95036c2cb17f9fe; branch=review/abg-v2-systems-r4; clean`
+> Accepted 上一阶段: `bcb2931356bb416f2bf617e3704d33bb8566e200`
+> Fixed product source: `db932cfc00af4e359babf8a81447b0affd0184fa`
+> Frozen spec: `.agent-taskgraph/spec.md` revision `design-spec-r3`
+> Graph node: `.agent-taskgraph/graph.yaml#v2_systems_review_r4` revision `graph-r9`
+> Independent contract: `docs/reviews/PRE_DEVELOPMENT_READINESS_AUDIT.md` at the fixed source
+> Context manifest: `context.md`
+> Context revision: `1`
+> Legal terminal: **ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 PASS** or **ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 FAIL: <earliest failed product boundary>** or **ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 INVALID: <review environment boundary>**
+
+## Objective
+
+Independently audit immutable revision `db932cfc00af4e359babf8a81447b0affd0184fa`
+from zero. Determine whether the generated-Recruit shop, ordered horizontal-line
+auto-battle, economy, progression, failure, save, pacing and complete mechanical
+content now form one executable and mutually consistent game design.
+
+## 图输入、输出与写入范围
+
+- 直接依赖（needs）：`v2_experience_reintegration`
+- 必须读取（consumes）：fixed source, design-spec-r3, current product/content authorities, validator and anti-dominance fixture/tool
+- 必须产出（produces）：one read-only PASS/FAIL/INVALID terminal with exact evidence
+- 唯一写入范围（writes）：none in the repository; reviewer-owned temporary evidence only
+- 路由：PASS -> `v2_review_synthesis`; FAIL/INVALID -> `failed`; 最大尝试 1
+
+## 分配记录
+
+- Role ref：`role:systems-integrity-reviewer-r4`
+- 角色职责：Independently verify fixed-revision loop, battle, economy, pacing, save, failure and mechanical content consistency
+- 角色生命周期：task-scoped
+- 派给：systems-integrity-reviewer-r4
+- 分配理由：职责匹配
+- 连续性：fresh R4 role and fresh HAPI session; R1-R3 are history only
+- 工作区：`/Users/wusumac/Documents/game/tmp/aetherbound-guild-worktrees/review-systems-r4`（分支：`review/abg-v2-systems-r4`）
+- Runtime requested：`runtime=hapi; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=bypassPermissions; visibility=visible`
+- Runtime observed：`runtime=hapi; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=yolo; visibility=visible`
+- Runtime verification：`VERIFIED; pre-dispatch 2026-08-11T10:55:11+08:00`
+- Session evidence：`HAPI ba21ab5a-b78f-4c30-ad12-94b457dcec71; PID 92956; verification cf950fcc-e946-4f10-955c-d0b05f30f8b2; runtime-evidence.json; zero-message watermark`
+- Dispatch bootstrap：`dispatch.md`
+- Dispatch message：`SENT: 2026-08-11T10:56:00+08:00 via HAPI peer; dispatch:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4:attempt-1`
+- Identity ACK：`VERIFIED: IDENTITY_READY dispatch_id=dispatch:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4:attempt-1 role=role:systems-integrity-reviewer-r4 team_revision=rev-6 goal=task:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 context_revision=1`
+- 完整启动方式：HAPI Hub helper spawn after fixed control worktree preflight
+
+## Required Gates
+
+1. Create a fresh archive of exactly `db932cf`, prove its commit ID/tree, and show canonical `main` still contains that revision with no product-authority diff after it.
+2. Run Python compile, validator self-test/full/JSON twice and anti-dominance self-test/replay; require cases=20, errors=0, byte-identical JSON, exact counts, five seeds and winner spread 1/2/1/1.
+3. Trace the first ten minutes and every cycle boundary with at least one legal player decision in every state, including provisional choose-two before run creation.
+4. Re-audit recruitment, refresh, hire, dismissal, last-Recruit prevention, reorder, equip, promotion, casualty replacement, retreat/defeat and explicit abandonment.
+5. Recalculate deterministic targeting, order, reach, movement, protection, critical, mitigation, Raw floor, status and every `AO_*` result including duplicate-trigger suppression.
+6. Recalculate prices, rewards, sinks, XP, levels, promotion, counter-items, solvency and all five fixed anti-dominance states from declared inputs.
+7. Reconcile pending/applied transactions, duplicate claims, interrupted writes, migration, corrupt primary/backup, rollback, clock rollback and bounded offline behavior.
+8. Verify five pacing profiles, exact decision timestamps and longest no-decision gaps against the 25-35h campaign, 60-80h build completion and roughly 100h collection envelope.
+9. Mechanically sample and cross-check all 42 professions, 36 traits, 320 equipment, 60 artifacts, 100 ordinary/elite enemies, 16 bosses and 8 regions for decision-bearing rules rather than names only.
+10. Stop at the earliest boundary. Product contradiction is FAIL; harness/import/command/evidence failure is INVALID. Do not repair or write the repository.
+
+## Frozen
+
+No repository writes, repair, commit, push, HTML, runtime, media, package or release actions. Human understanding/fun, visual/listening, device and release remain open after PASS.
@@ -0,0 +1,44 @@
+# Ledger: ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4
+
+| Field | Value |
+|---|---|
+| 任务 ID | ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 |
+| Goal ref | task:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 |
+| Goal current path | queue/failed/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4/goal.md |
+| Context manifest | context.md |
+| Context revision | 1 |
+| Role ref | role:systems-integrity-reviewer-r4 |
+| Role lifecycle | task-scoped |
+| Role profile | roles/systems-integrity-reviewer-r4/ROLE.md |
+| Role continuity | fresh R4 role and fresh HAPI session; R1-R3 are history only |
+| Reviewer Role ref | PENDING |
+| Reviewer Role profile | PENDING |
+| Frozen spec | .agent-taskgraph/spec.md design-spec-r3 |
+| Graph node | .agent-taskgraph/graph.yaml#v2_systems_review_r4 |
+| 依赖/路由 | needs: v2_experience_reintegration; PASS -> v2_review_synthesis; FAIL/INVALID -> failed |
+| 状态 | failed |
+| 负责人 | systems-integrity-reviewer-r4 |
+| 分配理由 | 职责匹配 |
+| 轮次 | 第 1 次 |
+| 开始时间 | 2026-08-11T10:44:55+08:00 |
+| 最后更新 | 2026-08-11T11:14:28+08:00 |
+| 验收结果 | FAIL: Gate 3 provisional Recruit pre-run determinism and transaction boundary |
+| 日志指针 | HAPI ba21ab5a; PID 92956; verification cf950fcc; runtime-evidence.json; `/tmp/abg-systems-review-r4.2KQ7fz/.review-evidence/terminal.txt` SHA `ca1c5279...` |
+| Runtime requested | runtime=hapi; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=bypassPermissions; visibility=visible |
+| Runtime observed | runtime=hapi; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=yolo; visibility=visible |
+| Runtime verification | VERIFIED |
+| Session ID | ba21ab5a-b78f-4c30-ad12-94b457dcec71 |
+| Runtime evidence | runtime-evidence.json |
+| Dispatch bootstrap | dispatch.md |
+| Dispatch message | SENT: 2026-08-11T10:56:00+08:00 via HAPI peer; dispatch:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4:attempt-1 |
+| Identity ACK | VERIFIED: IDENTITY_READY dispatch_id=dispatch:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4:attempt-1 role=role:systems-integrity-reviewer-r4 team_revision=rev-6 goal=task:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 context_revision=1 |
+| 等待归属 | 在等谁：PMO；等什么：route bounded pre-run seed/transaction repair |
+
+## State History
+
+| Time | From -> To | Operator | Evidence | Next |
+|---|---|---|---|---|
+| 2026-08-11T10:44:55+08:00 | created -> inbox | PMO | fixed source `db932cf`, graph-r9 and R4 dual-review authorization | create clean control worktree and verified HAPI session |
+| 2026-08-11T10:55:20+08:00 | inbox -> inbox | PMO | HAPI `ba21ab5a` pre-dispatch VERIFIED with zero-message watermark | commit binding and send rendered bootstrap |
+| 2026-08-11T11:00:42+08:00 | inbox -> active | PMO | bootstrap delivered; exact standalone rev-6 IDENTITY_READY observed before review commands | monitor without interrupting |
+| 2026-08-11T11:14:28+08:00 | active -> failed | PMO | legal FAIL on immutable `db932cf`; tree `21b7c81`; terminal SHA `ca1c527998f49fca13d27a7005166c3e44b269a9a204e27fae067bb9adf7c9db` | repair only seed authority and crash-safe transaction boundary |
@@ -0,0 +1,15 @@
+# ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 Report
+
+Terminal: `ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 FAIL: Gate 3 provisional Recruit pre-run determinism and transaction boundary`
+
+- Fixed source: `db932cfc00af4e359babf8a81447b0affd0184fa`
+- Fixed tree: `21b7c81886c02cd07a632d71df62e25911aa416c`
+- Reviewer: HAPI `ba21ab5a-b78f-4c30-ad12-94b457dcec71`
+- Archive: 241/241 blobs matched; manifest SHA-256 `0e255d5c87d47aa843fe35133824b043c6025f4c91ff786a2f6e487ee2854eec`
+- Terminal evidence: `/tmp/abg-systems-review-r4.2KQ7fz/.review-evidence/terminal.txt`; SHA-256 `ca1c527998f49fca13d27a7005166c3e44b269a9a204e27fae067bb9adf7c9db`
+
+Gates 1-2 passed: validator self-test `cases=20`, text/JSON `errors=0`, byte-identical JSON, anti-dominance seeds=5 and winner spread 1/2/1/1.
+
+The earliest contradiction is that the product requires choosing two provisional generated Recruits before the new Run seed exists, while recruit generation requires that saved run seed plus offer index. Save authority stores `run_seed` only inside `current_run`, has no provisional-selection transaction, and commits only after creation plus selection. Crash/retry therefore cannot reproduce the offer set or selected outputs.
+
+No later gate was promoted. The reviewer made no repository write.
@@ -0,0 +1,39 @@
+{
+  "status": "VERIFIED",
+  "phase": "pre-dispatch",
+  "verification_id": "cf950fcc-e946-4f10-955c-d0b05f30f8b2",
+  "goal_ref": "task:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4",
+  "session_id": "ba21ab5a-b78f-4c30-ad12-94b457dcec71",
+  "machine_id": "a15888ad-d405-4884-a407-c28ddd8b397c",
+  "machine_name": "小吴家",
+  "machine_host": "wusumacdeMac-mini.local",
+  "pid": "92956",
+  "flavor": "codex",
+  "cwd": "/Users/wusumac/Documents/game/tmp/aetherbound-guild-worktrees/review-systems-r4",
+  "model": "gpt-5.6-sol",
+  "effort": "xhigh",
+  "permission": "yolo",
+  "messages_received": 0,
+  "message_watermark": {
+    "latest_page_count": 0,
+    "latest_message_id": "",
+    "snapshot_head_seq": null,
+    "snapshot_head_at": null,
+    "epoch": 0,
+    "captured_at": "2026-08-11T02:55:11.455006+00:00"
+  },
+  "active": true,
+  "thinking": false,
+  "lifecycle": "running",
+  "catalog": {
+    "status": "VERIFIED",
+    "source": "/api/machines/:id/codex-models",
+    "checked_at": "2026-08-11T02:55:08.691942+00:00",
+    "model": "gpt-5.6-sol",
+    "effort": "xhigh",
+    "model_supported": true,
+    "effort_supported": true
+  },
+  "evidence": "HAPI Hub session metadata, model catalog, and message watermark",
+  "verified_at": "2026-08-11T02:55:11.455067+00:00"
+}