docs: record R4 design review failures
This commit is contained in:
@@ -87,3 +87,10 @@
|
||||
- Text and JSON validation return zero diagnostics, the validator self-test remains 20 cases, the five contradiction mutations remain rejected, and the five fixed policy seeds preserve a non-dominant winner spread. Result SHA-256: `17154371d4b93035296d1219f012f381af2e10a5f2c1b3f66bcfcd7ad4d85352`.
|
||||
- Create one PMO documentation closure and use that exact pushed revision as the sole immutable source for fresh Systems R4 and Experience R4 reviewers. No R1-R3 partial judgment may be reused as PASS.
|
||||
- HTML, engine work, final media, packaging and release remain frozen. Dual reviewer PASS leads only to PMO synthesis and the Owner design gate.
|
||||
|
||||
# 2026-08-11 - R4 Review Failure Routing
|
||||
|
||||
- Accept Systems R4 FAIL on immutable `db932cf`: provisional generated Recruits are selected before the only declared run seed exists, so offer reproduction, selection receipts and crash retry are undefined.
|
||||
- Accept Experience R4 FAIL on the same immutable source: `PF-H01..H06` content mechanics/production briefs and art parent/silhouette/motion bindings are inconsistent, with unresolved-binding language still present.
|
||||
- Route two disjoint minimal repairs in parallel: seed/transaction authority across the exact product/content documents, and hidden-profession binding inside the art catalog only. Do not broaden balance, content count, UI, audio, HTML, runtime or media scope.
|
||||
- After integration, add deterministic validator negatives for both R4 contradiction classes and create a new fixed revision. Only fresh dual reviewer PASS may reach the Owner gate.
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -16,8 +16,8 @@
|
||||
| experience-production-reviewer-v2 | 体验与生产审查员 | task-scoped | retired | 页面可理解性、内容呈现、美术动画、音频、可访问性与生产可行性 | task:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R2 | HAPI 8cfe0437-3a7e-4ac0-8b26-3477ef170654 | 2026-08-11 |
|
||||
| systems-integrity-reviewer-r3 | 系统完整性独立复审员 R3 | task-scoped | retired | 固定版本核心循环、战斗、经济、节奏、存档、失败与机械内容一致性 | task:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R3 | afcafe40-d67b-4372-a63a-6cb94c2e6127 | 2026-08-11 |
|
||||
| experience-production-reviewer-r3 | 体验与生产独立复审员 R3 | task-scoped | retired | 固定版本可理解性、页面覆盖、美术音频生产、可访问性与原创性 | task:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R3 | 44652407-b548-4f47-b78e-fca47657103f | 2026-08-11 |
|
||||
| systems-integrity-reviewer-r4 | 系统完整性独立复审员 R4 | task-scoped | assigned | 固定版本核心循环、战斗、经济、节奏、存档、失败与机械内容一致性 | task:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 | ba21ab5a-b78f-4c30-ad12-94b457dcec71 | 2026-08-11 |
|
||||
| experience-production-reviewer-r4 | 体验与生产独立复审员 R4 | task-scoped | assigned | 固定版本可理解性、页面覆盖、美术音频生产、可访问性与原创性 | task:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4 | 0e8eec99-d95f-4b98-a9bf-cb5ac46433e1 | 2026-08-11 |
|
||||
| systems-integrity-reviewer-r4 | 系统完整性独立复审员 R4 | task-scoped | retired | 固定版本核心循环、战斗、经济、节奏、存档、失败与机械内容一致性 | task:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 | ba21ab5a-b78f-4c30-ad12-94b457dcec71 | 2026-08-11 |
|
||||
| experience-production-reviewer-r4 | 体验与生产独立复审员 R4 | task-scoped | retired | 固定版本可理解性、页面覆盖、美术音频生产、可访问性与原创性 | task:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4 | 0e8eec99-d95f-4b98-a9bf-cb5ac46433e1 | 2026-08-11 |
|
||||
|
||||
## 编制变更历史
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -24,8 +24,6 @@
|
||||
| ABG-V2-CROSSDOC-VALIDATOR-REPAIR | R3 跨文档矛盾回归门 | failed | design-validator-v2 | 1/1 | 2026-08-11T10:17:06+08:00 | INVALID：真实整合文档出现 3 个 parser 假阴性；转 H1 |
|
||||
| ABG-V2-ANTI-DOMINANCE-SIMULATION-REPAIR | 固定种子构筑反支配模拟修复 | review | systems-designer | 1/1 | 2026-08-11T10:17:06+08:00 | `cb53794` -> `b65646c` 已整合；模拟与 hashes 通过；待 H1/R4 |
|
||||
| ABG-V2-CROSSDOC-VALIDATOR-H1 | 真实文档 validator 集成修复 | review | design-validator-v2 | 1/1 | 2026-08-11T10:44:55+08:00 | `49e128f` -> `bcb2931` 已整合；20-case/self/full/JSON 与反支配回放全绿；待 R4 双审 |
|
||||
| ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 | 系统完整性固定版本独立复审 | active | systems-integrity-reviewer-r4 | 1/1 | 2026-08-11T11:00:42+08:00 | HAPI `ba21ab5a` exact ACK；正在建 `db932cf` 独立归档并从 Gate 1 审查 |
|
||||
| ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4 | 体验与生产固定版本独立复审 | active | experience-production-reviewer-r4 | 1/1 | 2026-08-11T11:00:42+08:00 | HAPI `0e8eec99` exact ACK；正在建 `db932cf` 独立归档并从 Gate 1 审查 |
|
||||
|
||||
## 批次
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -37,4 +35,4 @@
|
||||
|
||||
## 当前批次总结
|
||||
|
||||
- 六条 R3 修复与 H1 validator 修复已整合到 `bcb2931`；20-case self-test、真实文档 text/JSON、固定种子反支配模拟均通过。下一步冻结唯一 closure revision 并开启 fresh R4 双 reviewer。HTML 与正式开发继续冻结。
|
||||
- R4 双 reviewer 均在固定 `db932cf` 上合法 FAIL：系统最早失败为开局 seed/事务确定性，体验最早失败为隐藏职业内容到美术绑定。前置 validator、反支配、引导、50 页面和队列可读性门通过。下一步仅做两个互斥最小修复；HTML 与正式开发继续冻结。
|
||||
|
||||
+7
-6
@@ -4,7 +4,7 @@
|
||||
|---|---|
|
||||
| 任务 ID | ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4 |
|
||||
| Goal ref | task:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4 |
|
||||
| Goal current path | queue/active/ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4/goal.md |
|
||||
| Goal current path | queue/failed/ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4/goal.md |
|
||||
| Context manifest | context.md |
|
||||
| Context revision | 1 |
|
||||
| Role ref | role:experience-production-reviewer-r4 |
|
||||
@@ -16,14 +16,14 @@
|
||||
| Frozen spec | .agent-taskgraph/spec.md design-spec-r3 |
|
||||
| Graph node | .agent-taskgraph/graph.yaml#v2_experience_review_r4 |
|
||||
| 依赖/路由 | needs: v2_experience_reintegration; PASS -> v2_review_synthesis; FAIL/INVALID -> failed |
|
||||
| 状态 | active |
|
||||
| 状态 | failed |
|
||||
| 负责人 | experience-production-reviewer-r4 |
|
||||
| 分配理由 | 职责匹配 |
|
||||
| 轮次 | 第 1 次 |
|
||||
| 开始时间 | 2026-08-11T10:44:55+08:00 |
|
||||
| 最后更新 | 2026-08-11T11:00:42+08:00 |
|
||||
| 验收结果 | PENDING |
|
||||
| 日志指针 | HAPI 0e8eec99; PID 92955; verification a57ca97c; runtime-evidence.json |
|
||||
| 最后更新 | 2026-08-11T11:14:28+08:00 |
|
||||
| 验收结果 | FAIL: Gate 7 hidden-hybrid profession content-to-art production binding |
|
||||
| 日志指针 | HAPI 0e8eec99; PID 92955; verification a57ca97c; runtime-evidence.json; `/tmp/abg-v2-experience-review-r4.4t4bzY/terminal.txt` SHA `a304e953...` |
|
||||
| Runtime requested | runtime=hapi; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=bypassPermissions; visibility=visible |
|
||||
| Runtime observed | runtime=hapi; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=yolo; visibility=visible |
|
||||
| Runtime verification | VERIFIED |
|
||||
@@ -32,7 +32,7 @@
|
||||
| Dispatch bootstrap | dispatch.md |
|
||||
| Dispatch message | SENT: 2026-08-11T10:56:00+08:00 via HAPI peer; dispatch:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4:attempt-1 |
|
||||
| Identity ACK | VERIFIED: IDENTITY_READY dispatch_id=dispatch:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4:attempt-1 role=role:experience-production-reviewer-r4 team_revision=rev-6 goal=task:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4 context_revision=1 |
|
||||
| 等待归属 | 在等谁：reviewer；等什么：one legal PASS/FAIL/INVALID terminal on fixed `db932cf` |
|
||||
| 等待归属 | 在等谁：PMO；等什么：route bounded hidden-profession art binding repair |
|
||||
|
||||
## State History
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -41,3 +41,4 @@
|
||||
| 2026-08-11T10:44:55+08:00 | created -> inbox | PMO | fixed source `db932cf`, graph-r9 and R4 dual-review authorization | create clean control worktree and verified HAPI session |
|
||||
| 2026-08-11T10:55:20+08:00 | inbox -> inbox | PMO | HAPI `0e8eec99` pre-dispatch VERIFIED with zero-message watermark | commit binding and send rendered bootstrap |
|
||||
| 2026-08-11T11:00:42+08:00 | inbox -> active | PMO | bootstrap delivered; exact standalone rev-6 IDENTITY_READY observed before review commands | monitor without interrupting |
|
||||
| 2026-08-11T11:14:28+08:00 | active -> failed | PMO | legal FAIL on immutable `db932cf`; tree `21b7c81`; terminal SHA `a304e953c8d6927a6d0a8273fc2a97c843174d5c1074a3bf3732457f1981ccb8` | repair only PF-H01..H06 art parent/silhouette/motion bindings |
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,14 @@
|
||||
# ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4 Report
|
||||
|
||||
Terminal: `ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4 FAIL: hidden-hybrid profession content-to-art production binding`
|
||||
|
||||
- Fixed source: `db932cfc00af4e359babf8a81447b0affd0184fa`
|
||||
- Fixed tree: `21b7c81886c02cd07a632d71df62e25911aa416c`
|
||||
- Reviewer: HAPI `0e8eec99-d95f-4b98-a9bf-cb5ac46433e1`
|
||||
- Terminal evidence: `/tmp/abg-v2-experience-review-r4.4t4bzY/terminal.txt`; SHA-256 `a304e953c8d6927a6d0a8273fc2a97c843174d5c1074a3bf3732457f1981ccb8`
|
||||
|
||||
Passed before failure: immutable-source verification, validator self/full/JSON, anti-dominance, first-play chain, 50-screen state coverage, horizontal-line readability and generated-Recruit crosswalk.
|
||||
|
||||
At Gate 7, content resolves `PF-H01..H06` parent pairs, mechanics and production briefs, while art retains unresolved parent bindings and assigns incompatible silhouettes/motion codes. Examples include H02 bell-hilt/cadence versus bow/vial `RELEASE/DEPLOY`, H03 bow-spear versus lantern/hammer `HEAVY/PULSE`, and H04 backpack automaton versus cord/folio `SWEEP/CHANNEL`.
|
||||
|
||||
No downstream audio/originality PASS was promoted. The reviewer made no repository write.
|
||||
+7
-6
@@ -4,7 +4,7 @@
|
||||
|---|---|
|
||||
| 任务 ID | ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 |
|
||||
| Goal ref | task:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 |
|
||||
| Goal current path | queue/active/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4/goal.md |
|
||||
| Goal current path | queue/failed/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4/goal.md |
|
||||
| Context manifest | context.md |
|
||||
| Context revision | 1 |
|
||||
| Role ref | role:systems-integrity-reviewer-r4 |
|
||||
@@ -16,14 +16,14 @@
|
||||
| Frozen spec | .agent-taskgraph/spec.md design-spec-r3 |
|
||||
| Graph node | .agent-taskgraph/graph.yaml#v2_systems_review_r4 |
|
||||
| 依赖/路由 | needs: v2_experience_reintegration; PASS -> v2_review_synthesis; FAIL/INVALID -> failed |
|
||||
| 状态 | active |
|
||||
| 状态 | failed |
|
||||
| 负责人 | systems-integrity-reviewer-r4 |
|
||||
| 分配理由 | 职责匹配 |
|
||||
| 轮次 | 第 1 次 |
|
||||
| 开始时间 | 2026-08-11T10:44:55+08:00 |
|
||||
| 最后更新 | 2026-08-11T11:00:42+08:00 |
|
||||
| 验收结果 | PENDING |
|
||||
| 日志指针 | HAPI ba21ab5a; PID 92956; verification cf950fcc; runtime-evidence.json |
|
||||
| 最后更新 | 2026-08-11T11:14:28+08:00 |
|
||||
| 验收结果 | FAIL: Gate 3 provisional Recruit pre-run determinism and transaction boundary |
|
||||
| 日志指针 | HAPI ba21ab5a; PID 92956; verification cf950fcc; runtime-evidence.json; `/tmp/abg-systems-review-r4.2KQ7fz/.review-evidence/terminal.txt` SHA `ca1c5279...` |
|
||||
| Runtime requested | runtime=hapi; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=bypassPermissions; visibility=visible |
|
||||
| Runtime observed | runtime=hapi; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=yolo; visibility=visible |
|
||||
| Runtime verification | VERIFIED |
|
||||
@@ -32,7 +32,7 @@
|
||||
| Dispatch bootstrap | dispatch.md |
|
||||
| Dispatch message | SENT: 2026-08-11T10:56:00+08:00 via HAPI peer; dispatch:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4:attempt-1 |
|
||||
| Identity ACK | VERIFIED: IDENTITY_READY dispatch_id=dispatch:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4:attempt-1 role=role:systems-integrity-reviewer-r4 team_revision=rev-6 goal=task:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 context_revision=1 |
|
||||
| 等待归属 | 在等谁：reviewer；等什么：one legal PASS/FAIL/INVALID terminal on fixed `db932cf` |
|
||||
| 等待归属 | 在等谁：PMO；等什么：route bounded pre-run seed/transaction repair |
|
||||
|
||||
## State History
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -41,3 +41,4 @@
|
||||
| 2026-08-11T10:44:55+08:00 | created -> inbox | PMO | fixed source `db932cf`, graph-r9 and R4 dual-review authorization | create clean control worktree and verified HAPI session |
|
||||
| 2026-08-11T10:55:20+08:00 | inbox -> inbox | PMO | HAPI `ba21ab5a` pre-dispatch VERIFIED with zero-message watermark | commit binding and send rendered bootstrap |
|
||||
| 2026-08-11T11:00:42+08:00 | inbox -> active | PMO | bootstrap delivered; exact standalone rev-6 IDENTITY_READY observed before review commands | monitor without interrupting |
|
||||
| 2026-08-11T11:14:28+08:00 | active -> failed | PMO | legal FAIL on immutable `db932cf`; tree `21b7c81`; terminal SHA `ca1c527998f49fca13d27a7005166c3e44b269a9a204e27fae067bb9adf7c9db` | repair only seed authority and crash-safe transaction boundary |
|
||||
@@ -0,0 +1,15 @@
|
||||
# ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 Report
|
||||
|
||||
Terminal: `ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 FAIL: Gate 3 provisional Recruit pre-run determinism and transaction boundary`
|
||||
|
||||
- Fixed source: `db932cfc00af4e359babf8a81447b0affd0184fa`
|
||||
- Fixed tree: `21b7c81886c02cd07a632d71df62e25911aa416c`
|
||||
- Reviewer: HAPI `ba21ab5a-b78f-4c30-ad12-94b457dcec71`
|
||||
- Archive: 241/241 blobs matched; manifest SHA-256 `0e255d5c87d47aa843fe35133824b043c6025f4c91ff786a2f6e487ee2854eec`
|
||||
- Terminal evidence: `/tmp/abg-systems-review-r4.2KQ7fz/.review-evidence/terminal.txt`; SHA-256 `ca1c527998f49fca13d27a7005166c3e44b269a9a204e27fae067bb9adf7c9db`
|
||||
|
||||
Gates 1-2 passed: validator self-test `cases=20`, text/JSON `errors=0`, byte-identical JSON, anti-dominance seeds=5 and winner spread 1/2/1/1.
|
||||
|
||||
The earliest contradiction is that the product requires choosing two provisional generated Recruits before the new Run seed exists, while recruit generation requires that saved run seed plus offer index. Save authority stores `run_seed` only inside `current_run`, has no provisional-selection transaction, and commits only after creation plus selection. Crash/retry therefore cannot reproduce the offer set or selected outputs.
|
||||
|
||||
No later gate was promoted. The reviewer made no repository write.
|
||||
@@ -6,11 +6,11 @@
|
||||
| Team revision | rev-6 |
|
||||
| Origin | initial:graph-r9 |
|
||||
| 生命周期 | task-scoped |
|
||||
| 状态 | assigned |
|
||||
| 状态 | retired |
|
||||
| 核心职责 | Independently verify fixed-revision comprehension, page coverage, visual/audio production feasibility, accessibility and originality |
|
||||
| 负责范围 | Read-only immutable `db932cf` archive and reviewer-owned temporary evidence |
|
||||
| 明确不负责 | Repair, repository writes, human acceptance, media generation, HTML, runtime, package or release |
|
||||
| 当前 Goal | task:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R4 |
|
||||
| 当前 Session ID | 0e8eec99-d95f-4b98-a9bf-cb5ac46433e1 |
|
||||
| 连续性记录 | fresh R4 role and fresh HAPI session; R1-R3 are history only |
|
||||
| 最后更新 | 2026-08-11T11:00:42+08:00 / PMO |
|
||||
| 连续性记录 | Fresh R4 review produced a product FAIL at Gate 7: PF-H01..H06 mechanics and production briefs do not match their art silhouettes and motion codes. |
|
||||
| 最后更新 | 2026-08-11T11:14:28+08:00 / PMO |
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -6,11 +6,11 @@
|
||||
| Team revision | rev-6 |
|
||||
| Origin | initial:graph-r9 |
|
||||
| 生命周期 | task-scoped |
|
||||
| 状态 | assigned |
|
||||
| 状态 | retired |
|
||||
| 核心职责 | Independently verify fixed-revision loop, battle, economy, pacing, save, failure and mechanical content consistency |
|
||||
| 负责范围 | Read-only immutable `db932cf` archive and reviewer-owned temporary evidence |
|
||||
| 明确不负责 | Repair, repository writes, presentation acceptance, media, HTML, runtime, package or release |
|
||||
| 当前 Goal | task:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 |
|
||||
| 当前 Session ID | ba21ab5a-b78f-4c30-ad12-94b457dcec71 |
|
||||
| 连续性记录 | fresh R4 role and fresh HAPI session; R1-R3 are history only |
|
||||
| 最后更新 | 2026-08-11T11:00:42+08:00 / PMO |
|
||||
| 连续性记录 | Fresh R4 review produced a product FAIL at Gate 3: provisional Recruit selection precedes the only declared run seed and lacks a recoverable transaction. |
|
||||
| 最后更新 | 2026-08-11T11:14:28+08:00 / PMO |
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
|
||||
# Recruit-Line Pre-Development Readiness Audit
|
||||
|
||||
Date: 2026-08-11
|
||||
Status: `READY_FOR_DUAL_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW`
|
||||
Status: `R4_REPAIR_REQUIRED`
|
||||
Integrated product source: `bcb2931`
|
||||
Frozen specification: `.agent-taskgraph/spec.md` revision `design-spec-r3`
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -17,6 +17,13 @@ feasibility. It is not yet owner-approved and does not authorize HTML
|
||||
prototype, engine, asset generation, audio generation, packaging or release
|
||||
work.
|
||||
|
||||
R4 completed on fixed closure `db932cf` with two product-design failures.
|
||||
Systems failed at the provisional Recruit seed/transaction boundary;
|
||||
Experience failed at the hidden-hybrid profession content-to-art production
|
||||
binding. The package is not ready for Owner acceptance or HTML reconstruction
|
||||
until both bounded repairs integrate, deterministic coverage advances, and a
|
||||
fresh dual review passes.
|
||||
|
||||
## Integrated Candidates
|
||||
|
||||
| Workstream | Candidate | Scope |
|
||||
@@ -156,8 +163,11 @@ gates; neither may reuse R1-R3 partial results as proof for the repaired source.
|
||||
|
||||
## Open Gates
|
||||
|
||||
- Two fresh independent reviewer terminals and PMO synthesis on one fixed clean
|
||||
revision.
|
||||
- Repair the provisional Recruit pre-run seed/transaction authority.
|
||||
- Repair `PF-H01..H06` content-to-art parent, silhouette and motion bindings.
|
||||
- Extend deterministic regression coverage for both R4 contradiction classes.
|
||||
- Two fresh independent reviewer terminals and PMO synthesis on one new fixed
|
||||
clean revision.
|
||||
- Owner acceptance of game direction, comprehension, choice quality and scope.
|
||||
- Rebuilt landscape HTML gallery and interactive design prototype.
|
||||
- Final art/audio generation, integration, human visual review and listening.
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user