From cce573a3d5d2e7d52635e444f9d67e9e1a63fff9 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: wusumac <736139669@qq.com> Date: Mon, 10 Aug 2026 18:51:50 +0800 Subject: [PATCH] docs: archive failed system design review --- .agent-taskgraph/STATUS.md | 3 +- .../ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/context.md | 0 .../ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/dispatch.md | 0 .../ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/goal.md | 0 .../ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/ledger.md | 17 +++++++---- .../queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/report.md | 30 +++++++++++++++++++ .../ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/reviewer-dispatch.md | 4 ++- .../reviewer-runtime-evidence.json | 0 .../roles/independent-reviewer/ROLE.md | 6 ++-- .../roles/systems-designer/ROLE.md | 6 ++-- 10 files changed, 51 insertions(+), 15 deletions(-) rename .agent-taskgraph/queue/{review => failed}/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/context.md (100%) rename .agent-taskgraph/queue/{review => failed}/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/dispatch.md (100%) rename .agent-taskgraph/queue/{review => failed}/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/goal.md (100%) rename .agent-taskgraph/queue/{review => failed}/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/ledger.md (79%) create mode 100644 .agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/report.md rename .agent-taskgraph/queue/{review => failed}/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/reviewer-dispatch.md (80%) rename .agent-taskgraph/queue/{review => failed}/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/reviewer-runtime-evidence.json (100%) diff --git a/.agent-taskgraph/STATUS.md b/.agent-taskgraph/STATUS.md index 2b0579f8..e30f7955 100644 --- a/.agent-taskgraph/STATUS.md +++ b/.agent-taskgraph/STATUS.md @@ -3,9 +3,8 @@ | 任务 ID | 标题 | 状态 | 负责人 | 轮次 | 最后更新 | 卡点 | |---|---|---|---|---|---|---| | ABG-REF-CENSUS | 参考游戏运行内容普查 | active | reference-researcher / 019feb14-e6ad-7352-ab6b-fd0a98dab3a7 | 2 | 2026-08-10T17:53:49+08:00 | 无；正在普查证据 | -| ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN | 原创系统与数值设计 | review | independent-reviewer / HAPI 0d777b9a | 2 | 2026-08-10T18:28:08+08:00 | 固定候选 22b21f8；等待 reviewer ACK/审查 | | ABG-WORLD-CONTENT | 世界、角色与完整内容矩阵 | active | content-architect / 019feb14-e6ad-7fb1-a168-01dc3e4f94ad | 2 | 2026-08-10T17:50:51+08:00 | 无；正在生成完整内容包 | ## 当前批次总结 -Batch 01：2 active / 1 review。系统候选 22b21f8 进入 HAPI 独立审查；其余两条继续执行。 +Batch 01：2 active / 1 failed。系统候选 22b21f8 被独立 reviewer 拒绝；参考候选已提交，世界内容继续执行，表现设计仍被系统失败阻断。 diff --git a/.agent-taskgraph/queue/review/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/context.md b/.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/context.md similarity index 100% rename from .agent-taskgraph/queue/review/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/context.md rename to .agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/context.md diff --git a/.agent-taskgraph/queue/review/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/dispatch.md b/.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/dispatch.md similarity index 100% rename from .agent-taskgraph/queue/review/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/dispatch.md rename to .agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/dispatch.md diff --git a/.agent-taskgraph/queue/review/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/goal.md b/.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/goal.md similarity index 100% rename from .agent-taskgraph/queue/review/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/goal.md rename to .agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/goal.md diff --git a/.agent-taskgraph/queue/review/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/ledger.md b/.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/ledger.md similarity index 79% rename from .agent-taskgraph/queue/review/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/ledger.md rename to .agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/ledger.md index ded33611..57710d52 100644 --- a/.agent-taskgraph/queue/review/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/ledger.md +++ b/.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/ledger.md @@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ |---|---| | 任务 ID | ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN | | Goal ref | task:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN | -| Goal current path | queue/review/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/goal.md | +| Goal current path | queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/goal.md | | Context manifest | context.md | | Context revision | 2 | | Role ref | role:systems-designer | @@ -15,17 +15,17 @@ | Reviewer Role profile | roles/independent-reviewer/ROLE.md | | Reviewer Session ID | 0d777b9a-451f-4787-bbee-e70074bfa2c6 | | Reviewer Runtime evidence | reviewer-runtime-evidence.json / verification a20bf601-38c5-45d9-b730-72b4adfd0e58 | -| Reviewer Dispatch | reviewer-dispatch.md / SENT 2026-08-10T18:29:29+08:00; ACK PENDING | +| Reviewer Dispatch | reviewer-dispatch.md / SENT 2026-08-10T18:29:29+08:00; exact ACK not observed; bound session delivered FAIL and cleanup terminal | | Frozen spec | `.agent-taskgraph/spec.md` design-spec-r1 | | Graph node | `.agent-taskgraph/graph.yaml#system_design` | | 依赖/路由 | needs: none; PASS -> presentation_design; FAIL -> failed | -| 状态 | review | +| 状态 | failed | | 负责人 | 019feb14-e6ad-77a0-b43d-ad3f0308c8ab / systems-designer | | 分配理由 | 职责匹配 | | 轮次 | 第 2 次 | | 开始时间 | 2026-08-10T17:53:04+08:00 | -| 最后更新 | 2026-08-10T18:28:08+08:00 | -| 验收结果 | PENDING | +| 最后更新 | 2026-08-10T18:46:00+08:00 | +| 验收结果 | FAIL: economy/save difficulty and failure contracts are contradictory | | 日志指针 | `/Users/wusumac/.codex/sessions/2026/08/10/rollout-2026-08-10T17-50-43-019feb14-e6ad-77a0-b43d-ad3f0308c8ab.jsonl` | | Runtime requested | runtime=codex-native; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=yolo; visibility=headless | | Runtime observed | runtime=codex-native; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=yolo; visibility=headless | @@ -35,7 +35,7 @@ | Dispatch bootstrap | dispatch.md | | Dispatch message | SENT: 2026-08-10T17:50:46+08:00 dispatch:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN:r2 via Codex CLI | | Identity ACK | VERIFIED: IDENTITY_READY dispatch_id=dispatch:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN:r2 role=role:systems-designer team_revision=rev-1 goal=task:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN context_revision=2 | -| 等待归属 | 在等谁：reviewer；等什么：固定提交 22b21f8 独立审查；静默多久算异常：20 分钟 | +| 等待归属 | 在等谁：Owner；等什么：是否批准同角色第二次有界修复及 graph/Goal delta；静默多久算异常：不适用 | ## PMO 诊断与控制记录 @@ -50,3 +50,8 @@ | 2026-08-10 | created -> inbox | PMO | Frozen spec + graph-r1 | r2 身份验证 | | 2026-08-10T17:53:04+08:00 | inbox -> active | PMO | 精确 r2 ACK + JSONL/线程证据 | 监控 candidate | | 2026-08-10T18:24:00+08:00 | active -> review | PMO | candidate 22b21f8；4 owned files；worker worktree clean | 创建 HAPI 可见 reviewer | +| 2026-08-10T18:46:00+08:00 | review -> failed | PMO | reviewer HAPI 0d777b9a legal terminal FAIL；`report.md` | 等 Owner 决定是否批准第二次产品尝试 | + +## Reviewer Cleanup + +`cleanup=COMPLETE reviewer_stopped=true candidate_unchanged=true owned_processes=none evidence_path=/sessions/0d777b9a-451f-4787-bbee-e70074bfa2c6` diff --git a/.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/report.md b/.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/report.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..b9b5a87b --- /dev/null +++ b/.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/report.md @@ -0,0 +1,30 @@ +# Review Report: ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN R1 + +| Field | Value | +|---|---| +| Result | FAIL | +| Legal terminal | `ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN redesign required: economy/save difficulty and failure contracts are contradictory` | +| Fixed candidate | `22b21f8749077a6b0a71e210be981b12d722ae45` | +| Reviewer | HAPI `0d777b9a-451f-4787-bbee-e70074bfa2c6` | +| Evidence | `/sessions/0d777b9a-451f-4787-bbee-e70074bfa2c6` | +| Earliest failed boundary | Cross-document battle/profession/economy/save contract consistency | + +## Blocking Findings + +1. `ECONOMY_AND_BALANCE.md` combines defeat and retreat at 25/50/100 percent Cache loss, while `SAVE_AND_FAILURE_CONTRACT.md` defines retreat as 15/30/60 percent with different Supply, Strain and route outcomes. +2. The save procedure can durably commit a pending operation and its deltas before a later applied child without a complete retry rule for that active-pending state. +3. The pacing budget supplies at most 1,560 minutes from 62 twenty-minute expeditions plus eight forty-minute confrontations, 140 minutes below its declared 1,700-minute lower bound; required five-profile decision timestamp traces are absent. +4. Solvency cannot be executed because counter-item purchase pricing, `xp_multiplier`, chapter level caps, spendable skill points and stat-budget conversion are undefined. The recruit formula can reach 301 despite a declared maximum of 250. +5. The indivisible Cache algorithm can remove zero value for a 25-value target over lines `[30,30,40]`, making item-heavy Cache composition a dominant loss-avoidance strategy. +6. The damage formula does not conditionally resolve critical hits or enforce the stated five-percent-of-Raw floor; its declared clamps can produce 1.67 percent Raw. + +## Passing Boundaries + +- Fixed candidate and reviewer worktree identity were correct and clean. +- The candidate changed only the four owned product design documents. +- Diff whitespace and relative links passed. +- Targeted originality checks found no copied commercial expression or assets. + +## PMO Disposition + +Candidate rejected. It must not be merged or consumed by presentation design. The approved graph routes this failure to `failed`; a bounded second product attempt requires an Owner-approved graph/Goal delta. diff --git a/.agent-taskgraph/queue/review/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/reviewer-dispatch.md b/.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/reviewer-dispatch.md similarity index 80% rename from .agent-taskgraph/queue/review/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/reviewer-dispatch.md rename to .agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/reviewer-dispatch.md index 8ad86333..83d2c32b 100644 --- a/.agent-taskgraph/queue/review/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/reviewer-dispatch.md +++ b/.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/reviewer-dispatch.md @@ -12,7 +12,9 @@ | Session ID | 0d777b9a-451f-4787-bbee-e70074bfa2c6 | | Runtime evidence | `reviewer-runtime-evidence.json`, verification `a20bf601-38c5-45d9-b730-72b4adfd0e58` | | Delivery | SENT: 2026-08-10T18:29:29+08:00 via HAPI 0d777b9a-451f-4787-bbee-e70074bfa2c6 | -| Identity ACK | PENDING | +| Identity ACK | NOT_OBSERVED: bound HAPI session delivered the fixed-candidate FAIL terminal; no PASS is granted | | Expected ACK | `IDENTITY_READY dispatch_id=dispatch:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN:review-r1 role=role:independent-reviewer team_revision=rev-1 goal=task:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN candidate=22b21f8` | Review only. Do not edit, commit, merge or repair the candidate. Verify exact scope, product/system/economy/save consistency, formulas, five-profile pacing, failure boundaries, originality, decision quality, dominant-strategy risks and implementability. Return PASS, FAIL or INVALID at the earliest boundary with commands/evidence. + +Cleanup terminal: `cleanup=COMPLETE reviewer_stopped=true candidate_unchanged=true owned_processes=none evidence_path=/sessions/0d777b9a-451f-4787-bbee-e70074bfa2c6`. diff --git a/.agent-taskgraph/queue/review/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/reviewer-runtime-evidence.json b/.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/reviewer-runtime-evidence.json similarity index 100% rename from .agent-taskgraph/queue/review/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/reviewer-runtime-evidence.json rename to .agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/reviewer-runtime-evidence.json diff --git a/.agent-taskgraph/roles/independent-reviewer/ROLE.md b/.agent-taskgraph/roles/independent-reviewer/ROLE.md index 905f61a6..18c22dc2 100644 --- a/.agent-taskgraph/roles/independent-reviewer/ROLE.md +++ b/.agent-taskgraph/roles/independent-reviewer/ROLE.md @@ -7,13 +7,13 @@ | Origin | initial:design-spec-r1 | | 名称 | 独立设计审查员 | | 生命周期 | task-scoped | -| 状态 | assigned | +| 状态 | retired | | 核心职责 | 固定版本只读审查原创性、完整性、一致性、决策密度、数值边界和可实现性 | | 负责范围 | `/Users/wusumac/Documents/game/tmp/aetherbound-guild-worktrees/system-review` 和 `.agent-taskgraph/queue/review/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/reviewer-*` | | 明确不负责 | 修复候选、修改四份产品文档、合并、运行时代码、内容和表现设计 | | 默认能力 | 固定提交审查、合同/公式交叉检查、失败边界和主导策略审计 | | 默认 Runtime | hapi; codex; gpt-5.6-sol; xhigh; yolo; visible | -| 当前 Goal | task:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN | +| 当前 Goal | none; ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN review completed FAIL | | 当前 Session ID | 0d777b9a-451f-4787-bbee-e70074bfa2c6 | -| 连续性记录 | 新 task-scoped reviewer；不继承 systems-designer 上下文 | +| 连续性记录 | 新 task-scoped reviewer；不继承 systems-designer 上下文；fixed candidate `22b21f8` returned FAIL and cleanup COMPLETE with no owned process | | 最后更新 | 2026-08-10 / PMO | diff --git a/.agent-taskgraph/roles/systems-designer/ROLE.md b/.agent-taskgraph/roles/systems-designer/ROLE.md index ef0ed22a..044ede47 100644 --- a/.agent-taskgraph/roles/systems-designer/ROLE.md +++ b/.agent-taskgraph/roles/systems-designer/ROLE.md @@ -7,13 +7,13 @@ | Origin | initial:design-spec-r1 | | 名称 | 系统与数值设计师 | | 生命周期 | persistent | -| 状态 | assigned | +| 状态 | paused | | 核心职责 | 原创玩家循环、战斗、职业、技能、经济、平衡、保存与失败合同 | | 负责范围 | `docs/product/` | | 明确不负责 | 参考普查、命名内容矩阵、表现文件、运行时代码 | | 默认能力 | 游戏系统、数值模型、状态选择、模拟和异常边界 | | 默认 Runtime | codex-native; codex; gpt-5.6-sol; xhigh; yolo; headless | -| 当前 Goal | task:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN | +| 当前 Goal | none; failed candidate `22b21f8` retained for bounded repair handoff | | 当前 Session ID | 019feb14-e6ad-77a0-b43d-ad3f0308c8ab | -| 连续性记录 | r1 两份未提交草稿由 r2 检查后决定是否接续；未自动接受 | +| 连续性记录 | r1 两份未提交草稿由 r2 检查后决定是否接续；r2 candidate `22b21f8` failed independent review on six contract-consistency boundaries; session retained only for possible Owner-approved repair | | 最后更新 | 2026-08-10 / PMO |