From fcc63a0a3a18594a8cccdf9c7fe238ff9fda9a2b Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: wusumac <736139669@qq.com> Date: Tue, 11 Aug 2026 13:39:13 +0800 Subject: [PATCH] pmo: record R5 systems contract mismatch --- .agent-taskgraph/PROJECT.md | 2 +- .agent-taskgraph/ROLES.md | 2 +- .agent-taskgraph/STATUS.md | 4 ++-- .../ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R5/dispatch.md | 2 +- .../ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R5/ledger.md | 5 +++-- .../ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/context.md | 0 .../ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/dispatch.md | 0 .../ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/goal.md | 0 .../ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/ledger.md | 11 ++++++----- .../failed/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/report.md | 18 ++++++++++++++++++ .../runtime-evidence.json | 0 .../systems-integrity-reviewer-r5/ROLE.md | 4 ++-- 12 files changed, 34 insertions(+), 14 deletions(-) rename .agent-taskgraph/queue/{active => failed}/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/context.md (100%) rename .agent-taskgraph/queue/{active => failed}/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/dispatch.md (100%) rename .agent-taskgraph/queue/{active => failed}/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/goal.md (100%) rename .agent-taskgraph/queue/{active => failed}/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/ledger.md (80%) create mode 100644 .agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/report.md rename .agent-taskgraph/queue/{active => failed}/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/runtime-evidence.json (100%) diff --git a/.agent-taskgraph/PROJECT.md b/.agent-taskgraph/PROJECT.md index 51ae89c0..d5005c55 100644 --- a/.agent-taskgraph/PROJECT.md +++ b/.agent-taskgraph/PROJECT.md @@ -53,7 +53,7 @@ | Pre-dispatch recovery | Identity/runtime failure before ACK with clean worktree and zero Goal edits is PMO-owned recovery, not a product attempt; retry automatically while runtime/scope/model/permission/cost remain unchanged | | Monitoring wait primitive | HAPI completion/blocker event + real timer cell; startup 90s, steady 600s; resume only with functions.wait(real cell_id) | | Monitoring observe primitive | inspect_peer/session metadata/messages + exact task ledger reconciliation | -| Monitoring target evidence | Systems R5 HAPI `a0ea4f06-a73d-47c4-bc0d-dad36c6d735d` active; Experience R5 A2 HAPI `2392ec4d-83e8-4df4-b06e-0a7d3fa8167b` pre-dispatch VERIFIED | +| Monitoring target evidence | Systems R5 HAPI `a0ea4f06-a73d-47c4-bc0d-dad36c6d735d` archived after invalid review-contract terminal; Experience R5 A2 HAPI `2392ec4d-83e8-4df4-b06e-0a7d3fa8167b` active | ## 共享文件锁 diff --git a/.agent-taskgraph/ROLES.md b/.agent-taskgraph/ROLES.md index ad9af73e..6fac12ad 100644 --- a/.agent-taskgraph/ROLES.md +++ b/.agent-taskgraph/ROLES.md @@ -23,7 +23,7 @@ | design-validator-r5-h2 | R4 矛盾回归验证工程师 | task-scoped | retired | 为 seed/事务与隐藏职业美术绑定建立语义正负回归门 | task:ABG-V2-R4-VALIDATOR-H2 | 0ab9a014-89c7-4527-857c-6928349d842a (archived) | 2026-08-11 | | design-validator-r5-h2-a2 | R4 矛盾回归验证工程师（替代尝试） | task-scoped | retired | 为 seed/事务与隐藏职业美术绑定建立语义正负回归门 | task:ABG-V2-R4-VALIDATOR-H2 | 2cf38e48-f8f9-4c61-adff-b822831c17c7 (archived) | 2026-08-11 | | design-validator-r5-h2-a3 | R4 矛盾回归验证工程师（握手恢复） | task-scoped | retired | 为 seed/事务与隐藏职业美术绑定建立语义正负回归门 | task:ABG-V2-R4-VALIDATOR-H2 | 1546960c-baf0-4a36-bd71-b1c39bc577b7 (archived) | 2026-08-11 | -| systems-integrity-reviewer-r5 | 系统完整性独立复审员 R5 | task-scoped | assigned | 固定源核心循环、战斗、经济、节奏、存档、失败与机械内容一致性 | task:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5 | a0ea4f06-a73d-47c4-bc0d-dad36c6d735d | 2026-08-11 | +| systems-integrity-reviewer-r5 | 系统完整性独立复审员 R5 | task-scoped | retired | 固定源核心循环、战斗、经济、节奏、存档、失败与机械内容一致性 | task:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5 | a0ea4f06-a73d-47c4-bc0d-dad36c6d735d (archived) | 2026-08-11 | | experience-production-reviewer-r5 | 体验与生产独立复审员 R5 | task-scoped | retired | 固定源可理解性、页面覆盖、美术音频生产、可访问性与原创性 | task:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R5 | c52000b5-2021-48cb-8d68-299f36876b8c (archived INVALID) | 2026-08-11 | | experience-production-reviewer-r5-a2 | 体验与生产独立复审员 R5 替代 | task-scoped | assigned | 固定源可理解性、页面覆盖、美术音频生产、可访问性与原创性 | task:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R5 | 2392ec4d-83e8-4df4-b06e-0a7d3fa8167b | 2026-08-11 | diff --git a/.agent-taskgraph/STATUS.md b/.agent-taskgraph/STATUS.md index f1dedce5..d97506c4 100644 --- a/.agent-taskgraph/STATUS.md +++ b/.agent-taskgraph/STATUS.md @@ -27,8 +27,8 @@ | ABG-V2-RUN-CREATION-TRANSACTION-REPAIR | 开局 seed 与可恢复事务修复 | review | run-creation-contract-repairer-r5 | 2/2 | 2026-08-11T11:58:55+08:00 | `ad0a57d` -> `bba0c43` 已整合；等待 H2 + fresh Systems R5 | | ABG-V2-HIDDEN-PROFESSION-ART-REPAIR | 隐藏职业内容到美术绑定修复 | review | hidden-profession-art-repairer-r5 | 2/2 | 2026-08-11T11:58:55+08:00 | `fef9057` -> `8102bd2` 已整合；`c558d19` 禁止；等待 H2 + fresh Experience R5 | | ABG-V2-R4-VALIDATOR-H2 | R4 seed/事务与隐藏职业绑定回归门 | done | design-validator-r5-h2-a3 | product 1/2; dispatch recovery 3 | 2026-08-11T13:06:00+08:00 | candidate `fb20b66` 整合为 `7dc584d`；24 cases/errors=0/JSON/5 seeds 通过；等待 R5 双审 | -| ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5 | 系统完整性固定源复审 | active | systems-integrity-reviewer-r5 | 1/1 | 2026-08-11T13:11:00+08:00 | full Goal 已发送；等待最终系统结论 | -| ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R5 | 体验与生产固定源复审 | active | experience-production-reviewer-r5-a2 | product judgment 0/1; environment recovery 2 | 2026-08-11T13:25:00+08:00 | exact rev-12 ACK verified；发送完整只读 Goal | +| ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5 | 系统完整性固定源复审 | failed | systems-integrity-reviewer-r5 | 1/1 | 2026-08-11T13:25:00+08:00 | reviewer Gate 1-8 PASS；Gate 9 使用错误时长 Goal，PMO 分类 INVALID_REVIEW_CONTRACT；Gate 10 未审 | +| ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R5 | 体验与生产固定源复审 | active | experience-production-reviewer-r5-a2 | product judgment 0/1; environment recovery 2 | 2026-08-11T13:26:00+08:00 | full fixed-source read-only Goal 已发送；等待终态 | ## 批次 diff --git a/.agent-taskgraph/queue/active/ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R5/dispatch.md b/.agent-taskgraph/queue/active/ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R5/dispatch.md index ff1013bd..d49fe455 100644 --- a/.agent-taskgraph/queue/active/ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R5/dispatch.md +++ b/.agent-taskgraph/queue/active/ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R5/dispatch.md @@ -14,6 +14,6 @@ | Continuity | fresh environment replacement; attempt-1 judgment invalid | | Session ID | 2392ec4d-83e8-4df4-b06e-0a7d3fa8167b | | Expected identity ACK | IDENTITY_READY dispatch_id=dispatch:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R5:attempt-2 role=role:experience-production-reviewer-r5-a2 team_revision=rev-12 goal=task:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R5 context_revision=2 | -| Delivery | PHASE1_ACK_VERIFIED; full Goal pending PMO send | +| Delivery | PHASE2_SENT: full fixed-source Goal via HAPI 2392ec4d at 2026-08-11T13:26:00+08:00 | | Identity ACK | VERIFIED: IDENTITY_READY dispatch_id=dispatch:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R5:attempt-2 role=role:experience-production-reviewer-r5-a2 team_revision=rev-12 goal=task:ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R5 context_revision=2 | | ACK evidence | exact HAPI response before review commands; worktree clean at 7ca0619 | diff --git a/.agent-taskgraph/queue/active/ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R5/ledger.md b/.agent-taskgraph/queue/active/ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R5/ledger.md index 595212cc..e5d6064b 100644 --- a/.agent-taskgraph/queue/active/ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R5/ledger.md +++ b/.agent-taskgraph/queue/active/ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R5/ledger.md @@ -18,7 +18,7 @@ | 状态 | active | | 负责人 | experience-production-reviewer-r5-a2 | | 轮次 | 1/1 | -| 最后更新 | 2026-08-11T13:25:00+08:00 | +| 最后更新 | 2026-08-11T13:26:00+08:00 | | 验收结果 | PENDING | | Runtime requested | runtime=hapi; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=yolo; visibility=visible | | Runtime observed | runtime=hapi; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=yolo; visibility=visible | @@ -26,7 +26,7 @@ | Session ID | 2392ec4d-83e8-4df4-b06e-0a7d3fa8167b | | Runtime evidence | runtime-evidence.json | | Dispatch bootstrap | dispatch.md | -| Dispatch message | PHASE1 sent; exact ACK verified; full Goal pending PMO send | +| Dispatch message | PHASE2_SENT: full fixed-source Goal via HAPI 2392ec4d at 2026-08-11T13:26:00+08:00 | | Identity ACK | VERIFIED exact standalone rev-12 ACK before review commands | | 等待归属 | Experience reviewer: PASS/FAIL/INVALID terminal | @@ -42,3 +42,4 @@ | 2026-08-11T13:14:00+08:00 | active -> inbox | PMO | shell harness failed before source judgment; STOP ignored; HAPI archived; worktree clean | fresh replacement attempt-2 | | 2026-08-11T13:20:00+08:00 | inbox -> inbox | PMO | fresh HAPI 2392ec4d pre-dispatch VERIFIED; exact runtime and zero-message watermark | commit binding then send identity-only bootstrap | | 2026-08-11T13:25:00+08:00 | inbox -> active | PMO | exact rev-12 ACK observed twice; worktree clean at 7ca0619 | commit activation then send full read-only Goal | +| 2026-08-11T13:26:00+08:00 | active -> active | PMO | full fixed-source read-only Goal delivered | observe until earliest terminal | diff --git a/.agent-taskgraph/queue/active/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/context.md b/.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/context.md similarity index 100% rename from .agent-taskgraph/queue/active/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/context.md rename to .agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/context.md diff --git a/.agent-taskgraph/queue/active/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/dispatch.md b/.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/dispatch.md similarity index 100% rename from .agent-taskgraph/queue/active/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/dispatch.md rename to .agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/dispatch.md diff --git a/.agent-taskgraph/queue/active/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/goal.md b/.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/goal.md similarity index 100% rename from .agent-taskgraph/queue/active/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/goal.md rename to .agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/goal.md diff --git a/.agent-taskgraph/queue/active/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/ledger.md b/.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/ledger.md similarity index 80% rename from .agent-taskgraph/queue/active/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/ledger.md rename to .agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/ledger.md index 1c159e05..7bf23986 100644 --- a/.agent-taskgraph/queue/active/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/ledger.md +++ b/.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/ledger.md @@ -4,7 +4,7 @@ |---|---| | 任务 ID | ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5 | | Goal ref | task:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5 | -| Goal current path | queue/active/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/goal.md | +| Goal current path | queue/failed/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/goal.md | | Context manifest | context.md | | Context revision | 1 | | Role ref | role:systems-integrity-reviewer-r5 | @@ -15,11 +15,11 @@ | Reviewer Role profile | roles/systems-integrity-reviewer-r5/ROLE.md | | Frozen spec | .agent-taskgraph/spec.md design-spec-r3 | | Graph node | .agent-taskgraph/graph.yaml#v2_systems_review_r5 | -| 状态 | active | +| 状态 | failed | | 负责人 | systems-integrity-reviewer-r5 | | 轮次 | 1/1 | -| 最后更新 | 2026-08-11T13:04:00+08:00 | -| 验收结果 | PENDING | +| 最后更新 | 2026-08-11T13:25:00+08:00 | +| 验收结果 | INVALID_REVIEW_CONTRACT; reviewer terminal preserved as FAIL | | Runtime requested | runtime=hapi; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=yolo; visibility=visible | | Runtime observed | runtime=hapi; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=yolo; visibility=visible | | Runtime verification | VERIFIED; zero-message pre-dispatch | @@ -28,7 +28,7 @@ | Dispatch bootstrap | dispatch.md | | Dispatch message | PHASE2_SENT: full Goal via HAPI a0ea4f06 at 2026-08-11T13:11:00+08:00 | | Identity ACK | VERIFIED exact standalone rev-11 ACK before commands | -| 等待归属 | Systems reviewer: PASS/FAIL/INVALID terminal | +| 等待归属 | PMO: corrected narrow Gate 9/10 disposition during synthesis | ## State History @@ -39,3 +39,4 @@ | 2026-08-11T13:08:00+08:00 | inbox -> inbox | PMO | HAPI a0ea4f06 VERIFIED; zero-message watermark | commit binding then identity-only delivery | | 2026-08-11T13:10:00+08:00 | inbox -> active | PMO | exact ACK observed; worktree clean at e4ef2b0 | commit activation; deliver full Goal | | 2026-08-11T13:11:00+08:00 | active -> active | PMO | full fixed-source read-only Goal delivered | startup observe then terminal | +| 2026-08-11T13:25:00+08:00 | active -> failed | PMO | reviewer Gates 1-8 PASS; Gate 9 compared against a PMO Goal that contradicts frozen spec; Gate 10 unsampled | preserve terminal; classify INVALID_REVIEW_CONTRACT | diff --git a/.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/report.md b/.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/report.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..d7c6b376 --- /dev/null +++ b/.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/report.md @@ -0,0 +1,18 @@ +# ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5 Report + +Reviewer terminal: `ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5 FAIL: Gate 9 pacing-envelope contradiction` + +- Fixed source: `69f6715b6f47b507fb07436ee1edf77df7e5adab` +- Reviewer: HAPI `a0ea4f06-a73d-47c4-bc0d-dad36c6d735d` (archived) +- Clean immutable archive: tree `f9e8f4b9`; `293/293` blobs +- Validator: `cases=24`, `errors=0`; deterministic JSON and five anti-dominance seeds passed + +Gates 1-8 passed. The reviewer stopped at Gate 9 because its PMO-authored Goal +required `25-35 h / 60-80 h / roughly 100 h`, while the frozen spec and fixed +product/economy authorities consistently require `15-25 h` first clear and +`60+ h` mastery. All five calculated first-clear profiles (`16.30`, `19.50`, +`23.20`, `22.00`, `21.75 h`) satisfy the actual frozen spec. + +PMO classification: `INVALID_REVIEW_CONTRACT`, not a product-design failure. +Gate 10 mechanical catalog sampling was not reached. No repository write was +made by the reviewer. diff --git a/.agent-taskgraph/queue/active/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/runtime-evidence.json b/.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/runtime-evidence.json similarity index 100% rename from .agent-taskgraph/queue/active/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/runtime-evidence.json rename to .agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/runtime-evidence.json diff --git a/.agent-taskgraph/roles/systems-integrity-reviewer-r5/ROLE.md b/.agent-taskgraph/roles/systems-integrity-reviewer-r5/ROLE.md index 0f7c698b..6768aab6 100644 --- a/.agent-taskgraph/roles/systems-integrity-reviewer-r5/ROLE.md +++ b/.agent-taskgraph/roles/systems-integrity-reviewer-r5/ROLE.md @@ -6,11 +6,11 @@ | Team revision | rev-11 | | Origin | staffing:ABG-V2-R5-DUAL-REVIEW | | 生命周期 | task-scoped | -| 状态 | assigned | +| 状态 | retired | | 核心职责 | Independently verify fixed-source loop, battle, economy, pacing, save, failure and mechanical content consistency | | 负责范围 | read-only fixed source and reviewer-owned temporary evidence | | 明确不负责 | Any repository write, repair, HTML, runtime product work, media, packaging or release | | 当前 Goal | task:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5 | | 当前 Session ID | a0ea4f06-a73d-47c4-bc0d-dad36c6d735d | | 连续性记录 | Fresh R5 identity; R1-R4 reviews are immutable history only. | -| 最后更新 | 2026-08-11T13:04:00+08:00 / PMO | +| 最后更新 | 2026-08-11T13:25:00+08:00 / PMO |