# ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5 Report

Reviewer terminal: `ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5 FAIL: Gate 9 pacing-envelope contradiction`

- Fixed source: `69f6715b6f47b507fb07436ee1edf77df7e5adab`
- Reviewer: HAPI `a0ea4f06-a73d-47c4-bc0d-dad36c6d735d` (archived)
- Clean immutable archive: tree `f9e8f4b9`; `293/293` blobs
- Validator: `cases=24`, `errors=0`; deterministic JSON and five anti-dominance seeds passed

Gates 1-8 passed. The reviewer stopped at Gate 9 because its PMO-authored Goal
required `25-35 h / 60-80 h / roughly 100 h`, while the frozen spec and fixed
product/economy authorities consistently require `15-25 h` first clear and
`60+ h` mastery. All five calculated first-clear profiles (`16.30`, `19.50`,
`23.20`, `22.00`, `21.75 h`) satisfy the actual frozen spec.

PMO classification: `INVALID_REVIEW_CONTRACT`, not a product-design failure.
Gate 10 mechanical catalog sampling was not reached. No repository write was
made by the reviewer.