# Goal: Independently review the fixed P9.1 runtime foundation

> Stage: foundation-independent-review
> Started: 2026-08-13T04:14:08+00:00
> Task ID: `ABG-P9.1-FOUNDATION-REVIEW-R1`
> Baseline: `c33c3042b10a1079674859a3f37b6d1fe3140c77; branch=review/abg-p91-foundation-r1; clean`
> Frozen spec: `.agent-taskgraph/spec.md revision p9.1-spec-r2; docs/runtime/PHASE9_1_ARBITRARY_PARTY_FIRST_SESSION_CONTRACT.md revision p9.1-contract-r2`
> Graph node: `.agent-taskgraph/graph.yaml#p91_runtime_foundation`
> Independent contract: 不适用
> Context manifest: `context.md`
> Context revision: `p91-foundation-review-r1`
> Legal terminal: **ABG-P9.1-FOUNDATION-REVIEW-R1 PASS** 或 **ABG-P9.1-FOUNDATION-REVIEW-R1 FAIL: <最早产品/合同失败边界>** 或 **ABG-P9.1-FOUNDATION-REVIEW-R1 INVALID: <最早 reviewer 环境/工具边界>**

## Objective

Independently review immutable source c33c304 from zero. Prove or reject behavior-equivalent extraction, one mutable state owner, composition-root compatibility, domain purity, exact accepted 22-script regression behavior and the four 844x390 presentation comparisons. Report PASS for a valid candidate, FAIL for a product/contract defect, or INVALID for reviewer environment/harness/input/import/timeout/cleanup failure. Stop at the earliest terminal and never repair.

## 图输入、输出与写入范围

- 直接依赖（needs）：p91_runtime_foundation candidate c33c304
- 必须读取（consumes）：c33c304 fixed source, p9.1-contract-r2, RUNTIME_ARCHITECTURE_SPEC, accepted exact 22-script R10 authority, developer evidence as non-authoritative history
- 必须产出（produces）：read-only PASS, FAIL or INVALID terminal with reviewer-owned evidence
- 唯一写入范围（writes）：none in repository; reviewer-owned isolated temporary evidence only
- 路由：PASS -> p91_domain_implementation；FAIL -> foundation repair or failed；最大尝试 1

## 分配记录

- Role ref：`role:p91-independent-reviewer`
- 角色职责：Review one immutable candidate from zero and report PASS, FAIL or INVALID without repairs
- 角色生命周期：task-scoped
- 派给：p91-independent-reviewer
- 分配理由：职责匹配
- 连续性：fresh visible reviewer session; no implementation conversation or evidence reuse; fixed source c33c304
- 工作区：`/Users/wusumac/Documents/game/tmp/aetherbound-guild-worktrees/p91-foundation-review`（分支：`review/abg-p91-foundation-r1`）
- Runtime requested：`runtime=hapi; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=yolo; visibility=visible`
- Runtime observed：`runtime=hapi; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=yolo; visibility=visible`
- Runtime verification：`VERIFIED pre-dispatch; verification 2f9bc176-851e-4a59-b838-8e7312e5ca56; zero-message watermark`
- Session evidence：`HAPI 9f8ea165-362e-4907-8c67-8aa0ace32fbd; PID 11995; runtime-evidence.json`
- Dispatch bootstrap：`dispatch.md`
- Dispatch message：`SENT: dispatch:ABG-P9.1-FOUNDATION-REVIEW-R1:attempt-1 via HAPI 9f8ea165 after pre-dispatch verification 2f9bc176`
- Identity ACK：`VERIFIED: IDENTITY_READY dispatch_id=dispatch:ABG-P9.1-FOUNDATION-REVIEW-R1:attempt-1 role=role:p91-independent-reviewer team_revision=rev-p9.1-1 goal=task:ABG-P9.1-FOUNDATION-REVIEW-R1 context_revision=p91-foundation-review-r1`
- 完整启动方式：派发预览批准后由所选 runtime 控制面生成

## 报告协议

- 完成、失败或阻塞时通知 PMO，并引用任务号、legal terminal 和证据路径。
- worker 不修改 PMO 管理的 queue ledger、STATUS 或角色注册表。

## 验收标准（证据门）

- [ ] Prove HEAD is exactly c33c304, direct candidate diff is exactly the 13 Goal-owned runtime files, and canonical/reviewer worktrees start clean
- [ ] Review every changed line for a real composition root, thin compatibility facade, one authoritative mutable state/service, atomic command results, exactly-once impacts, and no P9.1 gameplay/content implementation
- [ ] Prove runtime/domain/p9_1 has no Control-tree, input, audio, texture, renderer or frame-rate dependency and old run_state/tests/assets/main.tscn are byte-unchanged
- [ ] From fresh isolated imported source rerun exactly the accepted 22 scripts serially in their authoritative headless/normal modes; require one exact marker each and strict diagnostics zero
- [ ] Independently rerun the four named 844x390 baseline/candidate capture groups totaling 30 frames and compare behavior/pixels without reusing developer captures
- [ ] Verify reviewer-owned process cleanup, immutable source, clean worktrees and sanitized evidence inventory before terminal

## Frozen（禁止触碰，明确列出）

- Do not edit, repair, stage, commit, push, merge or modify any repository file or Git ref
- Do not reuse developer test logs/captures as reviewer execution evidence and do not read later product changes
- Do not implement downstream Domain/UI/Tests, generate media, package, sign, upload, publish or cross another Human Gate
- Classify harness/input/import/recording/timeout/concurrent-load/cleanup failures as INVALID, not product FAIL

## Estimate

fixed diff audit 45m; exact 22 tests 30-60m; independent 30-frame comparison 45-90m; confidence high

## 完成时交付

- graph 节点约定的 produces
- 验收证据与残余风险

## Review Terminal

- `ABG-P9.1-FOUNDATION-REVIEW-R1 FAIL: exact decision and content IDs`
- Fixed candidate: `c33c3042b10a1079674859a3f37b6d1fe3140c77`
- Earliest boundary: the frozen contract requires `retain_loan | add_recruit`; the new P9.1 domain API instead accepts, stores and emits `retain_item | recruit_rear`.
- Evidence: `/private/tmp/abg-p91-foundation-review-r1.iU9sRY/evidence/terminal.txt`, SHA-256 `790c5936d6bd0bd5c136d2a1ab9cdb1c0ff80b5b58a367313ae42bd4428bffc3`.
- Later tests/captures were not run because they cannot cure this contract defect. Reviewer source remained immutable and no owned process remained.