Goal: Independently review Foundation atomicity after tool-table preflight

Stage: foundation-atomicity-independent-rereview-r3 Started: 2026-08-13T09:14:30+00:00 Task ID: ABG-P9.1-FOUNDATION-ATOMICITY-REVIEW-R3 Baseline: 2dae30e1a6330a2dfbf2e3a83e74e6dcb2d66e73; branch=review/abg-p91-foundation-atomicity-r3; clean Frozen spec: .agent-taskgraph/spec.md revision p9.1-spec-r2; docs/runtime/PHASE9_1_ARBITRARY_PARTY_FIRST_SESSION_CONTRACT.md revision p9.1-contract-r2 Graph node: .agent-taskgraph/graph.yaml#p91_foundation_atomicity_h1 Independent contract: 不适用 Context manifest: context.md Context revision: p91-foundation-atomicity-review-r3 Legal terminal: ABG-P9.1-FOUNDATION-ATOMICITY-REVIEW-R3 PASS，或 ABG-P9.1-FOUNDATION-ATOMICITY-REVIEW-R3 FAIL: <最早产品失败边界>，或 ABG-P9.1-FOUNDATION-ATOMICITY-REVIEW-R3 INVALID: <最早 harness/环境/证据边界>

Objective

Review immutable f9b1b22 from zero. Before creating any reviewer-owned directory or running Godot, verify that every fixed executable exists and is executable: /bin/bash, /bin/mkdir, /usr/bin/find, /usr/bin/git, /usr/bin/shasum, /usr/bin/awk, /usr/bin/sed, /usr/bin/sort, /usr/bin/xargs, /bin/ps, /usr/bin/pgrep, /usr/bin/mktemp and /bin/cp. Then use Bash 3-compatible syntax only, never rm/unlink, and pass the guarded find-delete no-Godot preflight. Fresh archive/import and independently verify the complete public-command atomicity matrix, exact Guild IDs and legacy rejection. Copy the immutable accepted summary, require SHA-256 3de791bb..., and build the 22-script execution list by parsing each row's first token as mode and second token as script; verify exactly 12 headless and 10 normal. Apply --fixed-fps 60 to every parsed normal row. Fresh-capture rejected baseline bd505d6 and repaired candidate f9b1b22, four groups and 30 frames each, and require identical inventory and PNG bytes. Report PASS, product FAIL or harness INVALID at the earliest boundary; never repair.

图输入、输出与写入范围

直接依赖（needs）：p91_foundation_atomicity_h1 candidate f9b1b22
必须读取（consumes）：f9b1b22 fixed source, R5 FAIL ae6045c5, R1 INVALID d7d02847, R2 INVALID a5a70679, hash-fixed accepted summary 3de791bb
必须产出（produces）：fresh read-only PASS, FAIL or INVALID terminal with reviewer-owned sanitized evidence
唯一写入范围（writes）：none in repository; reviewer-owned isolated temporary evidence only
路由：PASS -> p91_domain_implementation；FAIL -> failed；最大尝试 1

分配记录

Role ref：role:p91-foundation-atomicity-reviewer-r3
角色职责：Independently verify immutable f9b1b22 after proving the fixed macOS executable table and authority-derived execution map
角色生命周期：task-scoped
派给：p91-foundation-atomicity-reviewer-r3
分配理由：职责匹配
连续性：fresh tool-path recovery after R2 INVALID; no prior reviewer execution evidence reuse
工作区：/Users/wusumac/Documents/game/tmp/aetherbound-guild-worktrees/p91-foundation-atomicity-review-r3（分支：review/abg-p91-foundation-atomicity-r3）
Runtime requested：runtime=hapi; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=yolo; visibility=visible
Runtime observed：runtime=hapi; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=yolo; visibility=visible
Runtime verification：VERIFIED pre-dispatch; verification 40daf9d5-129f-4c7f-a8ee-c613c92d3736; zero-message watermark
Session evidence：HAPI e5702d36-31e1-4ad1-ad51-1c9c151b22e5; PID 67138; runtime-evidence.json
Dispatch bootstrap：dispatch.md
Dispatch message：SENT: dispatch:ABG-P9.1-FOUNDATION-ATOMICITY-REVIEW-R3:attempt-1 via HAPI e5702d36 after pre-dispatch verification 40daf9d5
Identity ACK：VERIFIED: IDENTITY_READY dispatch_id=dispatch:ABG-P9.1-FOUNDATION-ATOMICITY-REVIEW-R3:attempt-1 role=role:p91-foundation-atomicity-reviewer-r3 team_revision=rev-p9.1-1 goal=task:ABG-P9.1-FOUNDATION-ATOMICITY-REVIEW-R3 context_revision=p91-foundation-atomicity-review-r3
完整启动方式：派发预览批准后由所选 runtime 控制面生成

报告协议

完成、失败或阻塞时通知 PMO，并引用任务号、legal terminal 和证据路径。
worker 不修改 PMO 管理的 queue ledger、STATUS 或角色注册表。

验收标准（证据门）

Before mkdir/mktemp/Godot, prove all 13 fixed executable paths exist and are executable; stop INVALID on the first missing tool
Pass Bash3-compatible no-Godot preflight: false rc=1, guarded absolute /private/tmp root and direct /usr/bin/find -depth -delete; no rm/unlink
Prove fixed f9b1b22, parent cf8d670, rejected ancestor bd505d6, exactly three authorized candidate paths, clean worktrees and fresh archives
Independently enumerate and verify every public mutator across success and rejection branches with complete internal-state fingerprints, exact Guild IDs and zero legacy leak
Verify accepted summary SHA 3de791bb; parse all 22 mode/script rows directly; derive exactly 12 headless/10 normal; every normal row uses --fixed-fps 60
Require every parsed script exit 0, emit its authority marker exactly once and strict diagnostics zero
Fresh-capture bd505d6 and f9b1b22 four groups/30 frames each; inventories and PNG bytes identical; sanitize/hash retained evidence and guarded cleanup

Frozen（禁止触碰，明确列出）

Do not edit, repair, stage, commit, push, merge or modify repository files or refs
Do not reuse developer, R1, R2 or prior Foundation reviewer execution logs/captures as R3 execution evidence
Do not hand-author or infer a separate 22-script mode map; execution order and mode must come from the hash-fixed summary rows
Do not invoke rm, unlink, zsh wrappers, mapfile, or variables named status/path; use /bin/bash, Bash 3 syntax, rc/review_root and guarded direct find-delete
Do not expose credentials, foreign process argv or machine-wide environment; retain only sanitized reviewer-owned facts and hashes
Do not implement downstream work, generate media, package, sign, upload, publish or cross Human Gates; harness failures are INVALID

Estimate

tool and source preflight 15m; independent atomicity matrix 30-60m; authority-parsed 22 scripts 30-60m; two-source 30-frame capture 45-90m; confidence high

完成时交付

graph 节点约定的 produces
验收证据与残余风险

Review Classification

PASS only when every declared gate passes on the immutable candidate.
FAIL only for a candidate product defect at the earliest declared product boundary.
INVALID for tool, shell, import, test harness, capture, cleanup, concurrent-load, environment or evidence-integrity failure that prevents a product judgment.
Stop at the first terminal boundary. Do not retry, repair, continue later gates or convert an INVALID into a product FAIL.

Review Terminal

ABG-P9.1-FOUNDATION-ATOMICITY-REVIEW-R3 INVALID: immutable source/scope harness.
Tool table and Bash 3 no-Godot preflight passed.
Earliest boundary: reviewer hand-authored an incorrect expected three-path set; actual Git scope was the correct H1-owned three paths.
Atomicity matrix, accepted 22 scripts and Godot were not executed; product judgment is none.
Evidence: /private/tmp/abg-p91-foundation-atomicity-r3.DgL7BF/, manifest SHA-256 47faede481b3ebe02d6e04e37153be6281b17fa1680db90b60408c5ecbdf0bce.

7.4 KiB Raw Blame History Unescape Escape