Files
aetherbound-guild/docs/design/ABG_GAME_TASTE_REVIEW.md
T

2.6 KiB

Aetherbound Guild — Game Taste Review Contract

Why this exists

There is no installed taste skill in the current Codex skill catalog. This project therefore owns a small, reviewable taste contract instead of relying on an uncheckable feeling of polish. It is a filter for Japanese 2D hand-drawn fantasy presentation, not a replacement for player testing.

Three-second read

In a new frame, without reading a paragraph, the viewer should identify:

  1. the painted world and the complete person/object that matters;
  2. the current Company/Contract fact that changes the decision; and
  3. the one legal next action and its immediate consequence.

If a dark panel, decorative frame or title is noticed before the world and subject, the composition fails.

Taste pillars

  • World first: soft painted depth, natural light, readable ground and props. Backgrounds are not flat gradients or UI posters.
  • Hand-authored material: thin ink contour, restrained cel color, paper, canvas, wood and weathered brass. Ornament supports meaning and stops before it crowds text or faces.
  • Actor/object-led decisions: a recruit, tool, route marker or reward has a readable silhouette and scale. It is not reduced to a tiny icon when it is the choice.
  • Quiet hierarchy: one primary action, one secondary route and a compact status rail. Empty space belongs to the world, not to unused dashboard rows.
  • Responsive integrity: fixed type and icon scale; adaptive spacing and surfaces; no crop, overlap, accidental matte or border distortion.

Reject signals

  • nested cards or a full-page opaque dashboard;
  • generic text rectangles pretending to be game controls;
  • green/magenta chroma spill, baked text or debug IDs in an element asset;
  • border/ornament larger than its content or repeated as visual noise;
  • state communicated only by color or a hidden tooltip;
  • a screenshot that passes geometry checks but does not say what to do next;
  • decorative motion that is not caused by a committed game state.

Review scorecard

Every candidate is marked pass, open or reject for: three-second read, focal order, material identity, actor readability, action affordance, state readability, responsive bounds and motion consequence. One reject on a load-bearing state keeps the presentation gate open.

Asset rule

AI generation is allowed only for a bounded, compatible batch. Source prompt, task ID, raw sheet, processing command, slice map, import state and runtime capture are retained. Text remains engine-rendered. A generated asset is not accepted until it is imported, gameplay-bound and inspected in a normal render.