2.2 KiB
2.2 KiB
Review Report: ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN R1
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Result | FAIL |
| Legal terminal | ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN redesign required: economy/save difficulty and failure contracts are contradictory |
| Fixed candidate | 22b21f8749077a6b0a71e210be981b12d722ae45 |
| Reviewer | HAPI 0d777b9a-451f-4787-bbee-e70074bfa2c6 |
| Evidence | /sessions/0d777b9a-451f-4787-bbee-e70074bfa2c6 |
| Earliest failed boundary | Cross-document battle/profession/economy/save contract consistency |
Blocking Findings
ECONOMY_AND_BALANCE.mdcombines defeat and retreat at 25/50/100 percent Cache loss, whileSAVE_AND_FAILURE_CONTRACT.mddefines retreat as 15/30/60 percent with different Supply, Strain and route outcomes.- The save procedure can durably commit a pending operation and its deltas before a later applied child without a complete retry rule for that active-pending state.
- The pacing budget supplies at most 1,560 minutes from 62 twenty-minute expeditions plus eight forty-minute confrontations, 140 minutes below its declared 1,700-minute lower bound; required five-profile decision timestamp traces are absent.
- Solvency cannot be executed because counter-item purchase pricing,
xp_multiplier, chapter level caps, spendable skill points and stat-budget conversion are undefined. The recruit formula can reach 301 despite a declared maximum of 250. - The indivisible Cache algorithm can remove zero value for a 25-value target over lines
[30,30,40], making item-heavy Cache composition a dominant loss-avoidance strategy. - The damage formula does not conditionally resolve critical hits or enforce the stated five-percent-of-Raw floor; its declared clamps can produce 1.67 percent Raw.
Passing Boundaries
- Fixed candidate and reviewer worktree identity were correct and clean.
- The candidate changed only the four owned product design documents.
- Diff whitespace and relative links passed.
- Targeted originality checks found no copied commercial expression or assets.
PMO Disposition
Candidate rejected. It must not be merged or consumed by presentation design. The approved graph routes this failure to failed; a bounded second product attempt requires an Owner-approved graph/Goal delta.