aetherbound-guild/.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R3/report.md

ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R3 Report

Terminal: ABG-V2-EXPERIENCE-REVIEW-R3 FAIL: run-creation/onboarding presentation coverage

• Fixed revision: d454120074057db0056bb8f117371f26de155e89
• Fixed tree: 17a336c
• Reviewer: HAPI 44652407-b548-4f47-b78e-fca47657103f
• Classification: product-design FAIL; no repository writes
• Temporary reviewer evidence: /tmp/abg-r3-experience-review.282vPK

Passed Before Failure

• Fixed archive and current authority diff were clean.
• Validator self-test passed 15 cases.
• JSON passed with ok=true, errors=0, pages=50, bindings=33 and exact content/audio counts.

Earliest Product Boundary

GAME_PRODUCT_CONTRACT.md requires selecting two of four provisional generated Recruits before run creation and then hiring two more. SYS-005 and the onboarding map specify difficulty/options and a normal Shop recruit, but no provisional-offer selection, comparison, revision or commit state.

Additional Blocking Contradictions

1. UI and art reverse the party-line direction.
2. Recruit-generation and recruit-art schemas use different field namespaces and incompatible counts without a deterministic crosswalk.
3. Audio omits OUT-006 and claims 49 rather than 50 screens.
4. TRANSFERABLE_STRUCTURE_LESSONS.md retains 30 named recruits and relationship scope contrary to design-spec-r3 generated-recruit authority.

No HTML, runtime, media, package, signing or release judgment occurred. The repair requires a new immutable revision and fresh R4 review; no R3 semantic acceptance may be reused.