1.2 KiB
1.2 KiB
ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 Report
Terminal: ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R4 FAIL: Gate 3 provisional Recruit pre-run determinism and transaction boundary
- Fixed source:
db932cfc00af4e359babf8a81447b0affd0184fa - Fixed tree:
21b7c81886c02cd07a632d71df62e25911aa416c - Reviewer: HAPI
ba21ab5a-b78f-4c30-ad12-94b457dcec71 - Archive: 241/241 blobs matched; manifest SHA-256
0e255d5c87d47aa843fe35133824b043c6025f4c91ff786a2f6e487ee2854eec - Terminal evidence:
/tmp/abg-systems-review-r4.2KQ7fz/.review-evidence/terminal.txt; SHA-256ca1c527998f49fca13d27a7005166c3e44b269a9a204e27fae067bb9adf7c9db
Gates 1-2 passed: validator self-test cases=20, text/JSON errors=0, byte-identical JSON, anti-dominance seeds=5 and winner spread 1/2/1/1.
The earliest contradiction is that the product requires choosing two provisional generated Recruits before the new Run seed exists, while recruit generation requires that saved run seed plus offer index. Save authority stores run_seed only inside current_run, has no provisional-selection transaction, and commits only after creation plus selection. Crash/retry therefore cannot reproduce the offer set or selected outputs.
No later gate was promoted. The reviewer made no repository write.