wushenghua/aetherbound-guild
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

docs: archive failed system design review

Browse Source
This commit is contained in:
wushenghua
2026-08-10 18:51:50 +08:00
parent 86ce719e9b
commit cce573a3d5
10 changed files with 51 additions and 15 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files
.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/context.md
+19
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,19 @@
# Context Manifest: ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN
> Task ID: `ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN`
> Revision: `2`
> Mode: `balanced`
> Budget exception: `none`
## 必须读取
| 路径或稳定引用 | Revision / 范围 | 为什么本 Goal 必须读 |
|---|---|---|
| `.agent-taskgraph/PROJECT.md` | design-batch-01 | 项目硬约束和执行配置 |
| `.agent-taskgraph/roles/systems-designer/ROLE.md` | rev-1 | 职责和写入边界 |
| `.agent-taskgraph/queue/active/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/dispatch.md` | dispatch:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN:r2 | 本次身份合同 |
| `.agent-taskgraph/spec.md` | design-spec-r1 | 完整产品设计范围 |
| `.agent-taskgraph/graph.yaml` | graph-r1#system_design | 节点产物和路由 |
| `README.md` | a1cf76b | 产品边界 |
| `AGENTS.md` | a1cf76b | 原创性与开发冻结边界 |
| `/Users/wusumac/Documents/game/reference_game_studies/dwarves_glory_death_loot/ANALYSIS_2026-08-09.md` | 2026-08-09 | 只作结构比较 |
.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/dispatch.md
+19
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,19 @@
# Dispatch Bootstrap: ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN
| 字段 | 值 |
|---|---|
| Task ID | ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN |
| Dispatch ID | dispatch:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN:r2 |
| Role ref | role:systems-designer |
| Role profile | roles/systems-designer/ROLE.md |
| Role lifecycle | persistent |
| Team revision | rev-1 |
| Goal ref | task:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN |
| Context manifest | context.md |
| Context revision | 2 |
| Continuity | 新角色 + r2 corrected dispatch |
| Session ID | 019feb14-e6ad-77a0-b43d-ad3f0308c8ab |
| Expected identity ACK | IDENTITY_READY dispatch_id=dispatch:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN:r2 role=role:systems-designer team_revision=rev-1 goal=task:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN context_revision=2 |
| Delivery | SENT: 2026-08-10T17:50:46+08:00 via Codex CLI dispatch:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN:r2 |
| Identity ACK | VERIFIED: IDENTITY_READY dispatch_id=dispatch:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN:r2 role=role:systems-designer team_revision=rev-1 goal=task:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN context_revision=2 |
| ACK evidence | Session 019feb14-e6ad-77a0-b43d-ad3f0308c8ab JSONL line 12 at `/Users/wusumac/.codex/sessions/2026/08/10/rollout-2026-08-10T17-50-43-019feb14-e6ad-77a0-b43d-ad3f0308c8ab.jsonl` |
.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/goal.md
+57
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,57 @@
# Goal: ABG Original Systems And Balance Design
> Stage: complete-design phase 1
> Started: 2026-08-10
> Task ID: `ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN`
> Baseline: `6047f50052b13b48b101f4cc41cde3afc7ea5e18`, branch `main`, clean
> Frozen spec: `.agent-taskgraph/spec.md` revision `design-spec-r1`
> Graph node: `.agent-taskgraph/graph.yaml#system_design`
> Context manifest: `context.md`
> Context revision: `2`
> Legal terminal: **ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN candidate ready** or **ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN redesign required: <earliest failed boundary>**
## Objective
Write the complete original player, systems, battle, economy, balance, save and failure contracts for Aetherbound Guild. The design must explain exactly what the player does, decides, learns, automates, risks, recovers and completes across seconds, expeditions, chapters, campaign and postgame.
## Outputs And Writes
- Needs: none
- Produces: `docs/product/GAME_PRODUCT_CONTRACT.md`, `SYSTEMS_AND_BATTLE.md`, `ECONOMY_AND_BALANCE.md`, `SAVE_AND_FAILURE_CONTRACT.md`
- Exclusive writes: `docs/product/`
- Route: PASS -> `presentation_design`; FAIL -> `failed`; maximum 2 attempts
## Required Design Depth
- Player fantasy, pillars/anti-pillars, 3-second read, 1-10 second actions, 30-180 second choices, session/campaign transformation and premium business boundary.
- Complete guild/preparation/route/auto-battle/intervention/result/recovery loop and the portfolio incremental chain: manual understanding -> visible automation -> readable bottleneck -> state-dependent choice -> persistent transformation -> different next cycle.
- Formation geometry, targeting, aggro, damage/heal/control, status effects, initiative/timing, AI telegraphs, speed/pause, tactical interventions, defeat diagnosis and recovery.
- 12 base/24 advanced profession contract and skill loadout/advancement/respec rules that content can instantiate.
- Recruitment, equipment, crafting/upgrading, currencies, sources/sinks, loot, route rewards, difficulty, chapter pacing, meta progression and postgame.
- Explicit formulas with tunable ranges and no dominant strategy assumptions.
- Five profiles: normal, active, efficient, adversarial and returning; target first campaign 25-35h, build completion 60-80h, full collection/high difficulty about 100h. Include meaningful-decision timestamps and maximum no-decision gaps.
- Save versioning/migration, corruption/backup, duplicate claim/action protection, interruption, clock rollback, bounded offline behavior and deterministic recovery.
- Tutorial through safe action -> guided decision -> independent test, plus accessibility/localization/input contracts.
## Assignment
- Role ref: `role:systems-designer`
- 角色职责: 原创玩家循环、战斗、职业、技能、经济、平衡、保存与失败合同
- 角色生命周期: persistent
- 连续性: 新角色 + r2 corrected dispatch
- 工作区: `/Users/wusumac/Documents/game/tmp/aetherbound-guild-worktrees/system-design`（分支：`agent/abg-system-design`）
- Runtime requested: `runtime=codex-native; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=yolo; visibility=headless`
- Runtime observed: `runtime=codex-native; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=yolo; visibility=headless`
- Runtime verification: VERIFIED: 2026-08-10T17:53:04+08:00 before task-bearing work
- Session evidence: thread `019feb14-e6ad-77a0-b43d-ad3f0308c8ab`; exec session `69324`; JSONL `/Users/wusumac/.codex/sessions/2026/08/10/rollout-2026-08-10T17-50-43-019feb14-e6ad-77a0-b43d-ad3f0308c8ab.jsonl`
- Dispatch bootstrap: `dispatch.md`
- Dispatch message: SENT: 2026-08-10T17:50:46+08:00 dispatch:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN:r2 via Codex CLI
- Identity ACK: VERIFIED: IDENTITY_READY dispatch_id=dispatch:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN:r2 role=role:systems-designer team_revision=rev-1 goal=task:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN context_revision=2
## Acceptance
All four documents are mutually consistent and implementation-ready as design authority; every important choice is state-dependent; formulas, boundaries, failure and save behavior are explicit; no copied reference expression; commit only owned files and leave worktree clean.
## Frozen
Do not edit reference/content/presentation/taskgraph files, implement runtime code, select an engine, generate production assets, package or publish.
.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/ledger.md
+57
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,57 @@
# 台账记录：ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN
| 字段 | 值 |
|---|---|
| 任务 ID | ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN |
| Goal ref | task:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN |
| Goal current path | queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/goal.md |
| Context manifest | context.md |
| Context revision | 2 |
| Role ref | role:systems-designer |
| Role lifecycle | persistent |
| Role profile | roles/systems-designer/ROLE.md |
| Role continuity | 新角色 + r2 corrected dispatch |
| Reviewer Role ref | role:independent-reviewer |
| Reviewer Role profile | roles/independent-reviewer/ROLE.md |
| Reviewer Session ID | 0d777b9a-451f-4787-bbee-e70074bfa2c6 |
| Reviewer Runtime evidence | reviewer-runtime-evidence.json / verification a20bf601-38c5-45d9-b730-72b4adfd0e58 |
| Reviewer Dispatch | reviewer-dispatch.md / SENT 2026-08-10T18:29:29+08:00; exact ACK not observed; bound session delivered FAIL and cleanup terminal |
| Frozen spec | `.agent-taskgraph/spec.md` design-spec-r1 |
| Graph node | `.agent-taskgraph/graph.yaml#system_design` |
| 依赖/路由 | needs: none; PASS -> presentation_design; FAIL -> failed |
| 状态 | failed |
| 负责人 | 019feb14-e6ad-77a0-b43d-ad3f0308c8ab / systems-designer |
| 分配理由 | 职责匹配 |
| 轮次 | 第 2 次 |
| 开始时间 | 2026-08-10T17:53:04+08:00 |
| 最后更新 | 2026-08-10T18:46:00+08:00 |
| 验收结果 | FAIL: economy/save difficulty and failure contracts are contradictory |
| 日志指针 | `/Users/wusumac/.codex/sessions/2026/08/10/rollout-2026-08-10T17-50-43-019feb14-e6ad-77a0-b43d-ad3f0308c8ab.jsonl` |
| Runtime requested | runtime=codex-native; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=yolo; visibility=headless |
| Runtime observed | runtime=codex-native; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=yolo; visibility=headless |
| Runtime verification | VERIFIED |
| Session ID | 019feb14-e6ad-77a0-b43d-ad3f0308c8ab |
| Runtime evidence | `/Users/wusumac/.codex/sessions/2026/08/10/rollout-2026-08-10T17-50-43-019feb14-e6ad-77a0-b43d-ad3f0308c8ab.jsonl` |
| Dispatch bootstrap | dispatch.md |
| Dispatch message | SENT: 2026-08-10T17:50:46+08:00 dispatch:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN:r2 via Codex CLI |
| Identity ACK | VERIFIED: IDENTITY_READY dispatch_id=dispatch:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN:r2 role=role:systems-designer team_revision=rev-1 goal=task:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN context_revision=2 |
| 等待归属 | 在等谁：Owner；等什么：是否批准同角色第二次有界修复及 graph/Goal delta；静默多久算异常：不适用 |
## PMO 诊断与控制记录
| 时间 | 事实 | 处理 | 下一步 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-08-10 | 外部审计声称三 Goal 仍在 inbox、Delivery=NOT_SENT；当前磁盘事实为本任务 `review`，worker dispatch 与身份 ACK 均已 VERIFIED，项目状态校验 PASS | 未重复创建 worker；向现有可见 HAPI reviewer 发送精确 `IDENTITY_READY` ACK 请求，保持候选固定且禁止修复 | 等 reviewer ACK 后开始固定候选只读审查；若 20 分钟无 ACK，诊断 HAPI 会话而非重派候选 |
## 状态转换历史
| 时间 | from -> to | 操作者 | 依据/证据 | 唯一下一步 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-08-10 | created -> inbox | PMO | Frozen spec + graph-r1 | r2 身份验证 |
| 2026-08-10T17:53:04+08:00 | inbox -> active | PMO | 精确 r2 ACK + JSONL/线程证据 | 监控 candidate |
| 2026-08-10T18:24:00+08:00 | active -> review | PMO | candidate 22b21f8；4 owned files；worker worktree clean | 创建 HAPI 可见 reviewer |
| 2026-08-10T18:46:00+08:00 | review -> failed | PMO | reviewer HAPI 0d777b9a legal terminal FAIL；`report.md` | 等 Owner 决定是否批准第二次产品尝试 |
## Reviewer Cleanup
`cleanup=COMPLETE reviewer_stopped=true candidate_unchanged=true owned_processes=none evidence_path=/sessions/0d777b9a-451f-4787-bbee-e70074bfa2c6`
.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/report.md
+30
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,30 @@
# Review Report: ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN R1
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Result | FAIL |
| Legal terminal | `ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN redesign required: economy/save difficulty and failure contracts are contradictory` |
| Fixed candidate | `22b21f8749077a6b0a71e210be981b12d722ae45` |
| Reviewer | HAPI `0d777b9a-451f-4787-bbee-e70074bfa2c6` |
| Evidence | `/sessions/0d777b9a-451f-4787-bbee-e70074bfa2c6` |
| Earliest failed boundary | Cross-document battle/profession/economy/save contract consistency |
## Blocking Findings
1. `ECONOMY_AND_BALANCE.md` combines defeat and retreat at 25/50/100 percent Cache loss, while `SAVE_AND_FAILURE_CONTRACT.md` defines retreat as 15/30/60 percent with different Supply, Strain and route outcomes.
2. The save procedure can durably commit a pending operation and its deltas before a later applied child without a complete retry rule for that active-pending state.
3. The pacing budget supplies at most 1,560 minutes from 62 twenty-minute expeditions plus eight forty-minute confrontations, 140 minutes below its declared 1,700-minute lower bound; required five-profile decision timestamp traces are absent.
4. Solvency cannot be executed because counter-item purchase pricing, `xp_multiplier`, chapter level caps, spendable skill points and stat-budget conversion are undefined. The recruit formula can reach 301 despite a declared maximum of 250.
5. The indivisible Cache algorithm can remove zero value for a 25-value target over lines `[30,30,40]`, making item-heavy Cache composition a dominant loss-avoidance strategy.
6. The damage formula does not conditionally resolve critical hits or enforce the stated five-percent-of-Raw floor; its declared clamps can produce 1.67 percent Raw.
## Passing Boundaries
- Fixed candidate and reviewer worktree identity were correct and clean.
- The candidate changed only the four owned product design documents.
- Diff whitespace and relative links passed.
- Targeted originality checks found no copied commercial expression or assets.
## PMO Disposition
Candidate rejected. It must not be merged or consumed by presentation design. The approved graph routes this failure to `failed`; a bounded second product attempt requires an Owner-approved graph/Goal delta.
.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/reviewer-dispatch.md
+20
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,20 @@
# Reviewer Dispatch: ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN-R1
| 字段 | 值 |
|---|---|
| Dispatch ID | dispatch:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN:review-r1 |
| Role ref | role:independent-reviewer |
| Team revision | rev-1 |
| Goal ref | task:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN |
| Fixed candidate | 22b21f8 |
| Worktree | `/Users/wusumac/Documents/game/tmp/aetherbound-guild-worktrees/system-review` |
| Model | gpt-5.6-sol / xhigh / yolo |
| Session ID | 0d777b9a-451f-4787-bbee-e70074bfa2c6 |
| Runtime evidence | `reviewer-runtime-evidence.json`, verification `a20bf601-38c5-45d9-b730-72b4adfd0e58` |
| Delivery | SENT: 2026-08-10T18:29:29+08:00 via HAPI 0d777b9a-451f-4787-bbee-e70074bfa2c6 |
| Identity ACK | NOT_OBSERVED: bound HAPI session delivered the fixed-candidate FAIL terminal; no PASS is granted |
| Expected ACK | `IDENTITY_READY dispatch_id=dispatch:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN:review-r1 role=role:independent-reviewer team_revision=rev-1 goal=task:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN candidate=22b21f8` |
Review only. Do not edit, commit, merge or repair the candidate. Verify exact scope, product/system/economy/save consistency, formulas, five-profile pacing, failure boundaries, originality, decision quality, dominant-strategy risks and implementability. Return PASS, FAIL or INVALID at the earliest boundary with commands/evidence.
Cleanup terminal: `cleanup=COMPLETE reviewer_stopped=true candidate_unchanged=true owned_processes=none evidence_path=/sessions/0d777b9a-451f-4787-bbee-e70074bfa2c6`.
.agent-taskgraph/queue/failed/ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN/reviewer-runtime-evidence.json
+39
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,39 @@
{
"status": "VERIFIED",
"phase": "pre-dispatch",
"verification_id": "a20bf601-38c5-45d9-b730-72b4adfd0e58",
"goal_ref": "task:ABG-SYSTEM-DESIGN",
"session_id": "0d777b9a-451f-4787-bbee-e70074bfa2c6",
"machine_id": "a15888ad-d405-4884-a407-c28ddd8b397c",
"machine_name": "小吴家",
"machine_host": "wusumacdeMac-mini.local",
"pid": "94584",
"flavor": "codex",
"cwd": "/Users/wusumac/Documents/game/tmp/aetherbound-guild-worktrees/system-review",
"model": "gpt-5.6-sol",
"effort": "xhigh",
"permission": "yolo",
"messages_received": 0,
"message_watermark": {
"latest_page_count": 0,
"latest_message_id": "",
"snapshot_head_seq": null,
"snapshot_head_at": null,
"epoch": 0,
"captured_at": "2026-08-10T10:28:08.535860+00:00"
},
"active": true,
"thinking": false,
"lifecycle": "running",
"catalog": {
"status": "VERIFIED",
"source": "/api/machines/:id/codex-models",
"checked_at": "2026-08-10T10:28:01.969621+00:00",
"model": "gpt-5.6-sol",
"effort": "xhigh",
"model_supported": true,
"effort_supported": true
},
"evidence": "HAPI Hub session metadata, model catalog, and message watermark",
"verified_at": "2026-08-10T10:28:08.535962+00:00"
}