pmo: record R5 systems contract mismatch

2026-08-11 13:39:13 +08:00
parent 41d824c635
commit fcc63a0a3a
12 changed files with 34 additions and 14 deletions
@@ -0,0 +1,16 @@
+# Context Manifest: ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5
+
+> Revision: `1`
+> Mode: `deep`
+
+| Required | Revision / scope | Reason |
+|---|---|---|
+| `AGENTS.md` | fixed source | role and design boundary |
+| canonical `.agent-taskgraph/PROJECT.md` | rev-11 | runtime/Frozen rules |
+| canonical reviewer ROLE/current dispatch/Goal | rev-11/context-1 | identity and gates |
+| `.agent-taskgraph/spec.md` + graph R5 node | design-spec-r3/graph-r11 | frozen contract/route |
+| H2 done report + Systems R4 FAIL report | fixed history | repaired boundary, not reusable PASS |
+| product/content authorities | fixed source | full systems judgment |
+| validator contract/tool + anti-dominance fixture/tool | fixed source | executable gates |
+
+Never read later product changes, worker chats, other games or superseded HTML/media into judgment.
@@ -0,0 +1,19 @@
+# Dispatch Bootstrap: ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5
+
+| Field | Value |
+|---|---|
+| Task ID | ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5 |
+| Dispatch ID | dispatch:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5:attempt-1 |
+| Role ref | role:systems-integrity-reviewer-r5 |
+| Role lifecycle | task-scoped |
+| Team revision | rev-11 |
+| Goal ref | task:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5 |
+| Context revision | 1 |
+| Continuity | fresh R5 reviewer; R1-R4 are history only |
+| Session ID | a0ea4f06-a73d-47c4-bc0d-dad36c6d735d |
+| Expected identity ACK | IDENTITY_READY dispatch_id=dispatch:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5:attempt-1 role=role:systems-integrity-reviewer-r5 team_revision=rev-11 goal=task:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5 context_revision=1 |
+| Delivery | PHASE2_SENT: exact ACK verified, then full Goal via HAPI a0ea4f06 at 2026-08-11T13:11:00+08:00 |
+| Identity ACK | VERIFIED: IDENTITY_READY dispatch_id=dispatch:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5:attempt-1 role=role:systems-integrity-reviewer-r5 team_revision=rev-11 goal=task:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5 context_revision=1 |
+| ACK evidence | exact standalone HAPI response before review commands; worktree clean at e4ef2b0 |
+
+Use two-stage identity-only delivery before reading or running review commands.
@@ -0,0 +1,48 @@
+# Goal: ABG-V2 Systems Integrity Review R5
+
+> Stage: fixed-revision pre-development independent review
+> Started: 2026-08-11T13:04:00+08:00
+> Task ID: `ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5`
+> Baseline: `e4ef2b0a01cd538c0e2e3d00afd3c67b947478db; branch=review/abg-v2-systems-r5; clean`
+> Fixed source: `69f6715b6f47b507fb07436ee1edf77df7e5adab`
+> Integrated H2: `7dc584d62fc4323746c927f5dc370e77f992f0c7`
+> Frozen spec: `.agent-taskgraph/spec.md revision design-spec-r3`
+> Graph node: `.agent-taskgraph/graph.yaml#v2_systems_review_r5 revision graph-r11`
+> Context revision: `1`
+> Legal terminal: **ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5 PASS** or **ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5 FAIL: <earliest product boundary>** or **ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5 INVALID: <review environment boundary>**
+
+## Objective
+
+Independently audit immutable source `69f6715` from zero. Determine whether the
+generated-Recruit shop, ordered horizontal-line auto-battle, economy,
+progression, failure, save, pacing and complete mechanical content form one
+executable, recoverable and mutually consistent game design.
+
+## Scope
+
+- Needs: `v2_r4_validator_h2`
+- Writes: none in the repository; reviewer-owned temporary evidence only
+- Route: PASS -> `v2_review_synthesis_r5`; FAIL/INVALID -> `failed`
+- Role: `role:systems-integrity-reviewer-r5`
+- Worktree: `/Users/wusumac/Documents/game/tmp/aetherbound-guild-worktrees/review-systems-r5`
+- Runtime requested: `runtime=hapi; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=yolo; visibility=visible`
+- Runtime observed/verification/session: `HAPI a0ea4f06-a73d-47c4-bc0d-dad36c6d735d; PID 20727; verification 6e5ee3d8-4bb0-4c9a-925d-05f1e887264d; Codex gpt-5.6-sol/xhigh/yolo VERIFIED`
+- Dispatch/Identity ACK: `phase-1 sent / exact rev-11 ACK VERIFIED before review commands`
+
+## Required Gates
+
+1. Archive exactly fixed source `69f6715`; prove commit/tree/blob inventory and no source drift.
+2. From zero run Python compile, validator self/full/JSON twice and anti-dominance self/replay; require cases=24, errors=0, byte-identical JSON and five non-dominant seeds.
+3. Reconstruct seed reservation, draft read-back, exact-four offer materialization, revisable exact-two receipt, atomic exactly-once promotion, crash retry and no-second-Run behavior; exercise both H2 mutation boundaries.
+4. Trace first ten minutes and every cycle boundary with legal state-dependent decisions, including provisional choose-two before Run creation.
+5. Re-audit recruitment, refresh, hire, dismissal, last-Recruit prevention, reorder, equip, promotion, casualty replacement, retreat/defeat and explicit abandonment.
+6. Recalculate deterministic targeting/order/reach/movement/protection/critical/mitigation/Raw floor/status and every `AO_*` outcome including duplicate suppression.
+7. Recalculate prices, rewards, sinks, XP, levels, promotion, counter-items, solvency and all five anti-dominance states.
+8. Reconcile all pending/applied transactions, duplicate claims, interrupted writes, migrations, corruption/backup, rollback, clock rollback and bounded offline behavior.
+9. Verify five pacing profiles, decision timestamps and longest no-decision gaps against the 25-35h / 60-80h / roughly 100h envelopes.
+10. Mechanically sample all 42 professions, 36 traits, 320 equipment, 60 artifacts, 100 ordinary/elite enemies, 16 bosses and 8 regions for decision-bearing rules.
+11. Stop at the earliest boundary. Product contradiction is FAIL; harness/evidence failure is INVALID. Do not repair or write the repository.
+
+## Frozen
+
+No repository write, repair, commit, push, HTML, runtime, media, package or release. Human understanding/fun, visual/listening, device and release remain open after PASS.
@@ -0,0 +1,42 @@
+# Ledger: ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5
+
+| Field | Value |
+|---|---|
+| 任务 ID | ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5 |
+| Goal ref | task:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5 |
+| Goal current path | queue/failed/ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5/goal.md |
+| Context manifest | context.md |
+| Context revision | 1 |
+| Role ref | role:systems-integrity-reviewer-r5 |
+| Role lifecycle | task-scoped |
+| Role profile | roles/systems-integrity-reviewer-r5/ROLE.md |
+| Role continuity | fresh R5 reviewer; R1-R4 are history only |
+| Reviewer Role ref | role:systems-integrity-reviewer-r5 |
+| Reviewer Role profile | roles/systems-integrity-reviewer-r5/ROLE.md |
+| Frozen spec | .agent-taskgraph/spec.md design-spec-r3 |
+| Graph node | .agent-taskgraph/graph.yaml#v2_systems_review_r5 |
+| 状态 | failed |
+| 负责人 | systems-integrity-reviewer-r5 |
+| 轮次 | 1/1 |
+| 最后更新 | 2026-08-11T13:25:00+08:00 |
+| 验收结果 | INVALID_REVIEW_CONTRACT; reviewer terminal preserved as FAIL |
+| Runtime requested | runtime=hapi; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=yolo; visibility=visible |
+| Runtime observed | runtime=hapi; flavor=codex; model=gpt-5.6-sol; effort=xhigh; permission=yolo; visibility=visible |
+| Runtime verification | VERIFIED; zero-message pre-dispatch |
+| Session ID | a0ea4f06-a73d-47c4-bc0d-dad36c6d735d |
+| Runtime evidence | runtime-evidence.json |
+| Dispatch bootstrap | dispatch.md |
+| Dispatch message | PHASE2_SENT: full Goal via HAPI a0ea4f06 at 2026-08-11T13:11:00+08:00 |
+| Identity ACK | VERIFIED exact standalone rev-11 ACK before commands |
+| 等待归属 | PMO: corrected narrow Gate 9/10 disposition during synthesis |
+
+## State History
+
+| Time | From -> To | Operator | Evidence | Next |
+|---|---|---|---|---|
+| 2026-08-11T13:04:00+08:00 | created -> inbox | PMO | fixed source 69f6715; H2 done; Team rev-11 | create worktree/runtime |
+| 2026-08-11T13:07:00+08:00 | inbox -> inbox | PMO | clean review worktree at `e4ef2b0`, branch `review/abg-v2-systems-r5` | verified HAPI spawn |
+| 2026-08-11T13:08:00+08:00 | inbox -> inbox | PMO | HAPI a0ea4f06 VERIFIED; zero-message watermark | commit binding then identity-only delivery |
+| 2026-08-11T13:10:00+08:00 | inbox -> active | PMO | exact ACK observed; worktree clean at e4ef2b0 | commit activation; deliver full Goal |
+| 2026-08-11T13:11:00+08:00 | active -> active | PMO | full fixed-source read-only Goal delivered | startup observe then terminal |
+| 2026-08-11T13:25:00+08:00 | active -> failed | PMO | reviewer Gates 1-8 PASS; Gate 9 compared against a PMO Goal that contradicts frozen spec; Gate 10 unsampled | preserve terminal; classify INVALID_REVIEW_CONTRACT |
@@ -0,0 +1,18 @@
+# ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5 Report
+
+Reviewer terminal: `ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5 FAIL: Gate 9 pacing-envelope contradiction`
+
+- Fixed source: `69f6715b6f47b507fb07436ee1edf77df7e5adab`
+- Reviewer: HAPI `a0ea4f06-a73d-47c4-bc0d-dad36c6d735d` (archived)
+- Clean immutable archive: tree `f9e8f4b9`; `293/293` blobs
+- Validator: `cases=24`, `errors=0`; deterministic JSON and five anti-dominance seeds passed
+
+Gates 1-8 passed. The reviewer stopped at Gate 9 because its PMO-authored Goal
+required `25-35 h / 60-80 h / roughly 100 h`, while the frozen spec and fixed
+product/economy authorities consistently require `15-25 h` first clear and
+`60+ h` mastery. All five calculated first-clear profiles (`16.30`, `19.50`,
+`23.20`, `22.00`, `21.75 h`) satisfy the actual frozen spec.
+
+PMO classification: `INVALID_REVIEW_CONTRACT`, not a product-design failure.
+Gate 10 mechanical catalog sampling was not reached. No repository write was
+made by the reviewer.
@@ -0,0 +1,39 @@
+{
+  "status": "VERIFIED",
+  "phase": "pre-dispatch",
+  "verification_id": "6e5ee3d8-4bb0-4c9a-925d-05f1e887264d",
+  "goal_ref": "task:ABG-V2-SYSTEMS-REVIEW-R5",
+  "session_id": "a0ea4f06-a73d-47c4-bc0d-dad36c6d735d",
+  "machine_id": "a15888ad-d405-4884-a407-c28ddd8b397c",
+  "machine_name": "小吴家",
+  "machine_host": "wusumacdeMac-mini.local",
+  "pid": "20727",
+  "flavor": "codex",
+  "cwd": "/Users/wusumac/Documents/game/tmp/aetherbound-guild-worktrees/review-systems-r5",
+  "model": "gpt-5.6-sol",
+  "effort": "xhigh",
+  "permission": "yolo",
+  "messages_received": 0,
+  "message_watermark": {
+    "latest_page_count": 0,
+    "latest_message_id": "",
+    "snapshot_head_seq": null,
+    "snapshot_head_at": null,
+    "epoch": 0,
+    "captured_at": "2026-08-11T05:07:30.749253+00:00"
+  },
+  "active": true,
+  "thinking": false,
+  "lifecycle": "running",
+  "catalog": {
+    "status": "VERIFIED",
+    "source": "/api/machines/:id/codex-models",
+    "checked_at": "2026-08-11T05:07:29.126390+00:00",
+    "model": "gpt-5.6-sol",
+    "effort": "xhigh",
+    "model_supported": true,
+    "effort_supported": true
+  },
+  "evidence": "HAPI Hub session metadata, model catalog, and message watermark",
+  "verified_at": "2026-08-11T05:07:30.749432+00:00"
+}